Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Morris v. CarShield: Call Recordings Come In, Disputed Consent Records Stay Out, and a Rule 11 Warning
In Morris v. NRRM, LLC d/b/a CarShield, No. 4:25-cv-00441-SEP (E.D. Mo. Mar. 30, 2026), Judge Pitlyk denied a motion to dismiss Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) Do Not Call claims that rested on the seller's own consent evidence. The order draws a clear line between what a defendant may and may not attach to a Rule 12(b)(6) motion, and it closes with an unusual reminder to both sides about their Rule 11 obligations.
On this page
Background
The plaintiff alleged that, although his number was on the National Do Not Call Registry, the vehicle service contract seller called him seven times in less than an hour, that he had no prior relationship with the company, and that he asked it to stop. He asserted claims under 47 C.F.R. § 64.1200(c) (national registry) and § 64.1200(d) (internal do not call list).
The seller moved to dismiss on consent and attached recordings and transcripts of three calls, printouts of a web form it said the plaintiff submitted along with its consent language, and an internal chronology of events. The plaintiff responded with a sworn declaration that he never visited the website or submitted any information, and that the IP address on the form suggested the "consent" originated internally.
What the Court Considered
Under Eighth Circuit law, a court may consider documents "necessarily embraced" by the pleadings, meaning materials whose contents the complaint alleges and whose authenticity is not disputed.
Recordings: considered. The complaint described the calls, and the plaintiff disputed only their completeness, not their authenticity. The court used the audio rather than the transcripts, because tone and volume may matter.
Web form printouts: excluded. The complaint alleged no prior interaction with the seller, and the plaintiff disputed the documents' authenticity. The court distinguished Zean v. Fairview Health Services, 858 F.3d 520 (8th Cir. 2017), where the complaint itself alleged a contractual relationship.
Chronology: excluded. It went beyond the complaint, including entries such as "Info Request Submitted (IP Consent Captured)," which the plaintiff contested.
The Recordings Did Not Establish Consent
On one call, the representative referred to "information [Plaintiff] requested" and the plaintiff confirmed vehicle details. The court found that "hardly decisive proof of consent." A representative's statement is not proof of the plaintiff's request; not every request for information is consent to telemarketing; and the seller could have obtained the vehicle information elsewhere. Nor did three recordings disprove the allegation that the plaintiff asked the seller to stop during at least seven calls. Both claims survived.
Taylor on a web form submitted by a third party
The Rule 11 Reminder
The court observed that each side's position implied serious misconduct by the other: either the seller fabricated material evidence or the plaintiff gave false testimony under penalty of perjury. It made no finding, acknowledged there may be an innocent explanation, and encouraged both parties and counsel to review their filings for compliance with Rule 11 and other legal and ethical norms.
Practical Implications
Sellers relying on web form consent should expect disputed lead records to be excluded at the pleading stage and should be prepared to authenticate them in discovery, including IP and timestamp data. Courts will consider recordings when the complaint describes the calls, but a few recordings will not defeat allegations about calls that were not recorded. Consent remains an affirmative defense, which is rarely resolved on a motion to dismiss.
Read the Eastern District of Missouri order in Morris v. CarShield.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
