Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Zean v. Fairview Health Services: Consent Forms Can Get a TCPA Case Dismissed Early
Typically consent is a fact fight that waits for summary judgment. In Zean v. Fairview Health Services, No. 16-1747, 858 F.3d 520 (8th Cir. May 26, 2017) the Eighth Circuit allowed a defendant to win on a motion to dismiss by pointing to the plaintiff's very own signed consent forms, even heavily redacted ones.
On this page
The calls
Fairview Health Services is a Minnesota nonprofit that operates hospitals and clinics and sells medical devices as Fairview Home Medical Equipment. Samuel Zean purchased a device from Fairview in September 2014 that requires regular replacement supplies like masks, filters and tubing.
He then got about 25 automated calls on his cell phone asking if he wanted replacement supplies. Voicemails were two and a half minutes long and told him to press one for supplies or two if not. He said he asked an employee to stop, and the employee agreed. The complaint didn't say when that happened or allege any calls afterward.
Zean filed a class action under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) alleging no prior express consent. Fairview moved to dismiss and attached two redacted documents. One, signed August 29, 2014, said: "I give permission for Fairview and its approved agents to contact me by phone (including my cell phone). This may include the use of auto-dialers or pre-recorded messages." The other, a 2013 questionnaire, showed his cell number. Fairview said it had redacted them to comply with health privacy laws. The District of Minnesota dismissed.
What the court held
Judge Loken wrote for the majority, joined by Judge Murphy.
Consent matters at the pleading stage. Zean argued that consent is an affirmative defense as the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) treats it. The court said that didn't matter. An affirmative defense apparent from the complaint and the documents it embraces can support dismissal. The court didn't decide whether the caller bears only the burden of producing evidence or the full burden of persuasion.
Van Patten on the scope of consent
The forms were "embraced by the pleadings." Courts can consider contract documents on a motion to dismiss, even ones that refute the claim. Zean's claim arose from his purchase from Fairview, and his "no consent" allegation was conclusory.
Authenticity was a "bogus issue." Zean objected to the redactions but never argued the documents weren't authentic, never denied signing them, never consented to unredacted disclosure and never asked to convert the motion to summary judgment. The court suggested that was tactical, since opening those fact issues could hurt class certification.
The calls were within the scope of consent. The calls about replacement supplies related to his services and accounts, and they served as reminders, even if Fairview also wanted his business.
The dissent
Judge Kelly dissented. She said the exhibits were heavily redacted, the only one with a phone number predated the purchase by a year, and Zean did object. She would have required conversion to summary judgment and remanded.
Why this matters
For healthcare and other businesses, clear written consent can end a case before discovery, at least in the Eighth Circuit.
Practical points:
- Use plain consent language that covers cell phones, autodialers and prerecorded messages.
- Keep the signed forms retrievable and connected to the right transaction.
- Keep calls related to the purpose the customer gave the number for.
- Plaintiffs should squarely contest authenticity and ask to convert when exhibits are disputed.
Read the Eighth Circuit's opinion in Zean v. Fairview Health Services.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
