Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Thompson v. Genesco: Both Sides Wanted Federal Court, and the Judge Sent the Text Message Case Back Anyway
Usually someone is fighting about standing. In Thompson v. Genesco, Inc., No. 4:23-cv-00292-SRC (E.D. Mo. Jan. 8, 2024), nobody was. The retailer removed the case, both sides said the plaintiff had standing, and Chief Judge Stephen R. Clark still raised the issue on his own and sent the case back to Missouri state court.
On this page
The Claim
The plaintiff alleged that for years the retailer sent him "numerous" and "annoying" marketing texts without consent, while his cell number sat on the National Do Not Call Registry and Missouri's no-call list. His original state court petition included registry claims. After removal, he amended down to a single Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) count under 47 C.F.R. § 64.1200(d), the internal do not call rule. He alleged the retailer lacked a written policy, did not train staff, and did not keep a list of people asking not to be contacted.
When the retailer moved for judgment on the pleadings and pointed out that registry claims belong under § 64.1200(c), the plaintiff doubled down. He was bringing a (d) claim and only a (d) claim. The court took him at his word: he is the master of his complaint.
Injury? Yes
The Eighth Circuit had not decided whether unwanted texts cause a concrete injury, so the court decided it fresh. It followed the Eleventh Circuit's decision in Drazen v. Pinto, 74 F.4th 1336 (11th Cir. 2023), and noted that the Second, Seventh and Ninth Circuits agree. Unwanted texts resemble the old tort of intrusion upon seclusion. Allegations that the texts made his phone buzz and intruded on his peace and privacy were enough.
Traceability? No
Here is the catch. The internal list rule requires a list of people who ask not to be contacted. The plaintiff never alleged he asked the retailer to stop texting him. So even a perfectly maintained list would never have included his number, and he would have gotten exactly the same texts. His injury was not traceable to the missing list.
The retailer tried to keep the case by citing an Eighth Circuit data breach case where a general causation allegation was enough. The court said that case involved an actual causal link between the security failure and the harm. Here there was none beyond the fact that the texts came from the retailer.
The court said that the Eleventh Circuit's decision in Cordoba v. DIRECTV, LLC, 942 F.3d 1259 (11th Cir. 2019), was "precisely on point." There, class members who never asked DIRECTV to stop calling could not trace their injuries to its lack of an internal do not call list.
Back to State Court
The retailer wanted a merits ruling on its motion, but a court without jurisdiction cannot rule on the merits. Because the case had been removed, the absence of standing meant remand instead of dismissal. The motions were denied as moot.
Takeaways
- Plaintiffs: An internal list claim needs a stop request. Without one, plead the registry claim under § 64.1200(c).
- Defendants: Removing a case does not lock in federal jurisdiction. The judge can check standing any time, and the case may go back.
- Everyone: Drafting choices after removal can decide where a case ends up.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
