Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Taylor v. Bruce Fink, D.D.S., P.C.: A Stranger's Web Form Isn't Your Consent
Picture this: you start getting texts and a voicemail about dental implants, addressed to someone with a completely different name. That's the setup in Taylor v. Bruce Fink, D.D.S., P.C., No. 1:25-cv-3099-TWT (N.D. Ga. Feb. 3, 2026), where Judge Thrash denied a dental practice's motion to dismiss a Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) Do Not Call case.
On this page
Messages for Someone Else
The plaintiff says her number is on the National Do Not Call Registry. She got a voicemail and texts soliciting dental services. The messages were addressed to another person by their first name and implied that her number had been submitted for an inquiry about a dental implant consultation. She says she never had any relationship with the practice, wasn't looking for dental work, and never gave written consent. She sued, with class allegations.
The Practice's Defense: "Somebody Filled Out Our Form"
The practice attached an affidavit from an employee of a dental advertising firm they had hired. According to the affidavit, someone with a different name filled out an online implant questionnaire and listed the plaintiff's number, and submitting that form authorizes contact from the advertising firm by phone, email, or text. The practice therefore argued that the plaintiff consented or had a business relationship.
Why That Didn't Work
The court couldn't look at it yet. On a motion to dismiss, a court can only consider an outside document if it's central to the claim and undisputed. The plaintiff disputed this one, and the judge said she had good reason: the form came from someone else, and the practice's name didn't appear on it anywhere. The court declined to convert the motion to summary judgment this early.
Even if it could, it probably wouldn't help. The Do Not Call rules allow calls to registered numbers only with the subscriber's prior express invitation or permission, shown by a signed, written agreement between the consumer and the seller that says the consumer agrees to be contacted by that seller and lists the phone number. A form submitted by another person, sent to an ad firm, and missing the seller's name, didn't look like that to the court.
Consent is the defendant's job to prove. Lack of consent isn't an element the plaintiff has to plead around. Her statement that she didn't consent was enough at this stage. Since the class-allegation challenge rested on the same failed argument, it went down too.
The Lesson
Lead forms are only as good as the person filling them out. If someone types in the wrong number, whether by mistake or on purpose, the actual owner of that phone never agreed to anything. And a form that authorizes contact from an advertising firm doesn't automatically authorize contact from the firm's client.
Morris v. CarShield on disputed consent records
For businesses buying leads: make sure consent language names you as the seller, and watch for red flags like a lead name that doesn't match the person who answers. If a reply says "wrong number," stop.
For consumers: keep those misaddressed messages. They help show the number didn't come from you.
Read the Northern District of Georgia order in Taylor v. Bruce Fink, D.D.S., P.C..
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
