Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Adler v. American Express: A Cardholder's Arbitration Clause Covers Robocalls About Someone Else's Debt
When a business calls a customer about an account that is not the customer's, can it take advantage of the customer's own arbitration agreement? In Adler v. American Express Company, No. 1:24-cv-00311 (N.D. Ohio Mar. 25, 2025), Judge Bridget Meehan Brennan held that it can, compelling arbitration of a Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) claim, and staying the case.
On this page
Background
The plaintiff had opened five American Express cards between 2011 and 2023 and provided the bank with two phone numbers related to those accounts. Each cardmember agreement, governed by Utah and federal law, contained an arbitration clause with a class waiver and 45-day window to reject arbitration. The clause covered any claim "relating to your Account(s), this Agreement, or any agreement or relationship you have or had with us," expressly including statutory claims.
The plaintiff alleged that the bank for years called him almost daily, often leaving 21-second prerecorded messages, and that when he answered, agents told him about a $20,000 "corporate debt" on accounts that were not his. He claimed that he told the bank of the error more than ten times and revoked any consent, but calls continued at least fifteen times a month, sometimes three times a day. He sued under the TCPA for damages, declaratory relief and an injunction. After answering, the bank moved to compel arbitration.
Agreement to Arbitrate
Under the Sixth Circuit's framework, the court first asked whether a valid agreement existed. Utah law makes a credit agreement binding when the debtor receives the written terms, the agreement says use constitutes acceptance, and the debtor then uses the credit. The bank's records showed all three, and Utah law permits arbitration and class waivers in open-end credit contracts. Although the plaintiff did not recall receiving the agreements, he did not contest the records or deny using the cards and did not contest that the clauses were valid.
Scope
The real dispute was scope. The plaintiff argued that the calls concerned "foreign accounts" he never held, so neither he nor the calls fell within the agreement, which defines "you" as the account applicant or anyone agreeing to pay. He warned that the bank's reading would sweep virtually any future dispute into arbitration.
The court sided with the bank. Doubts about scope are resolved in favor of arbitration, and the party resisting arbitration bears the burden. Although the calls concerned another person's debt, they reached the plaintiff because of his status as a cardmember: he gave the bank his numbers in connection with his own accounts and accepted the agreements by using his cards. The clause covers claims relating to his accounts and relationship with the bank and expressly includes statutory claims. The plaintiff did not carry his burden.
Stay Rather Than Dismissal
Although the entire case would be arbitrated, the court stayed it, following Sixth Circuit guidance that a stay rather than a dismissal better serves the Federal Arbitration Act's appellate review structure. The plaintiff must notify the court within thirty days of the end of arbitration.
Observations
- Relationship language is broad. Clauses covering any claim relating to the parties' "relationship" can reach calls about unrelated accounts.
- The number's origin matters. The court emphasized the fact that the plaintiff provided the called numbers in relation to his accounts.
- Contrast with lead form cases. Unlike disputes over whether a consumer ever accepted website terms, formation here was not contested.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
