Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
A.D. v. Credit One Bank: Picking Up a Smoothie Doesn't Bind a Teenager to Mom's Credit Card Arbitration Clause
Here's a fun one about arbitration, teenagers, and smoothies. In A.D. v. Credit One Bank, N.A., 885 F.3d 1054 (7th Cir. 2018), a bank tried to force a minor's robocall class action into arbitration because she once used her mother's credit card to pay for drinks at a mall. The Seventh Circuit wasn't buying it.
On this page
Judge Ripple wrote the opinion for the panel.
How a Teen's Phone Got Into the System
The mother opened a credit card account in 2003. In 2010, she called the bank from her daughter's cell phone to access the account, and the bank's caller ID capture software attached the daughter's number to the mother's account. When the mother fell behind on payments, the bank called the stored numbers. The daughter alleged she received a good number of calls in late 2014 about a debt she didn't owe.
She sued under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) as a putative class action. After eighteen months of discovery, the bank figured out the connection and moved to compel arbitration under the mother's cardholder agreement. That agreement covered claims by anyone "connected with" the cardholder, "such as a co-applicant or authorized user."
The bank's hook? In 2014, when the daughter was fourteen, her mother preordered smoothies at a mall stand and sent her to pick them up and pay with the card. The district court found that made her an "Authorized User" bound by direct benefits estoppel, then certified the question for appeal.
Not an Authorized User
The Seventh Circuit read the agreement as a whole. Becoming an Authorized User required a specific process: the cardholder asks the bank, the bank issues a card in the user's name, and a $19 annual fee applies. Authorized Users also had to be at least fifteen. None of that happened, and the daughter was too young anyway.
Even assuming multiple kinds of authorized users existed, two problems remained. She never agreed to arbitrate. And as a minor, she lacked capacity to contract and disaffirmed any obligation by filing suit. The court also rejected the bank's waiver argument, since the bank bore the burden of showing she was bound.
No Estoppel Either
Under Nevada law, which the parties accepted, the bank tried two estoppel theories:
- Direct benefit: The only "benefit" was following her mother's instructions to pick up smoothies her mother ordered. That came from the parent-child relationship, not the contract. Her mother, not she, benefited from the agreement.
- Claim based on the contract: The bank argued that because consent under the cardholder agreement was its defense, her TCPA claim depended on the contract. The court called this argument "entirely without merit." Consent is an affirmative defense the caller must prove, not part of the plaintiff's case. Her claim arose under a separate statute.
By adopting the bank's argument, the court warned, would "threaten to overwhelm the fundamental premise that a party cannot be compelled to arbitrate a matter without its agreement."
Why It Matters
- Caller ID capture has consequences. Grabbing whatever number someone calls from can lead to calls to people who never agreed to anything.
- Non-signatories are hard to bind. Arbitration clauses reach third parties only in limited circumstances.
- A consent defense doesn't convert a TCPA claim into a contract claim.
Reversed and remanded, with the class certification denial open for reconsideration since the class waiver didn't apply either.
Read the full Seventh Circuit opinion.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
