Analysis · Litigation & decisions
Starling v. OnProcess Technology: Court Enjoins a Carrier From Forcing a Non-Customer Into Arbitration Over Prerecorded Calls
When a company calls the wrong person, it cannot use its customer's arbitration clause to pull that person out of court. In Starling v. OnProcess Technology, Inc., No. 1:23-cv-10949-JEK (D. Mass. Mar. 25, 2024), Judge Julia E. Kobick denied a stay pending arbitration and enjoined the telecommunications company from arbitrating against the plaintiff, who was not its customer.
On this page
Background
The plaintiff's sister had an internet services account with the carrier. Her account agreements contained broad arbitration provisions covering "authorized or unauthorized users or beneficiaries" of the service. The plaintiff's cell number was listed as an alternate contact on that account. Who listed it was disputed but not material.
After the sister cancelled service in January 2023, a vendor acting for the carrier placed prerecorded calls seeking return of equipment. The plaintiff received several. She later answered one, said "yes" when the recording asked if she was her sister, and obtained the account number from her sister during the call. She sued under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) on behalf of a putative class of people called about accounts that were not theirs.
The court had already denied the vendor's motion to compel arbitration because the plaintiff was not a signatory, an agent, or an authorized user. The carrier then filed its own motion to stay on a new theory and initiated arbitration against both sisters.
No Direct Benefits Estoppel
The parties agreed Massachusetts law applied, and Texas law would produce the same result. Under direct benefits estoppel, a nonsignatory who knowingly exploits a contract, such as by suing under it, can be bound by its arbitration clause. The benefit must flow directly from the agreement.
The court held the plaintiff received no such benefit. A TCPA claim is not a benefit of an internet service contract. It is an independent federal cause of action. The carrier conceded she never used her sister's service. The court followed A.D. v. Credit One Bank, N.A., 885 F.3d 1054 (7th Cir. 2018), which refused to bind a TCPA plaintiff to her mother's cardholder agreement, and distinguished Ribadeneira v. New Balance Athletics, Inc., 65 F.4th 1 (1st Cir. 2023), where the nonsignatory had previously sued to enforce the contract itself.
The carrier's "but for" argument failed too. The claim arose from prerecorded calls that predated the conduct the carrier criticized. Nothing showed that she exploited the contract.
No Discretionary Stay
The court also declined a discretionary stay. An award purporting to bind a nonparty would likely exceed the arbitrator's authority, and the carrier did not show preclusive effect. Consent is an affirmative defense the caller must prove, not an element of the plaintiff's claim, citing Breda v. Cellco Partnership, 934 F.3d 1 (1st Cir. 2019).
The Injunction
Section 4 of the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) authorizes enjoining arbitration as the counterpart to compelling it. Under the four-factor test, the plaintiff was likely to succeed, and the expense of defending an invalid arbitration was irreparable harm given her strong merits position. Arbitration is a matter of consent, not coercion. The plaintiff's request for sanctions was denied.
Practical Points
- Alternate contact numbers in customer records are not customer consent and do not carry the customer's arbitration clause.
- Starting arbitration against a nonsignatory invites an injunction.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- Memorandum and Order, Starling v. OnProcess Technology, Inc., No. 1:23-cv-10949-JEK (D. Mass. Mar. 25, 2024)
- A.D. v. Credit One Bank, N.A., 885 F.3d 1054 (7th Cir. 2018)
- Ribadeneira v. New Balance Athletics, Inc., 65 F.4th 1 (1st Cir. 2023)
- Breda v. Cellco Partnership, 934 F.3d 1 (1st Cir. 2019)
- Memorandum and Order, Starling v. OnProcess Technology, Inc. (D. Mass. Mar. 25, 2024).
