Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
VonDeylen v. Aptive Environmental: An Old Pest Control Contract Doesn't Make Texts Sent Years Later Arbitrable
Arbitration clauses are written to be broad. "Any controversy... relating to... the relationship between you and" the company sounds like it covers everything. In VonDeylen v. Aptive Environmental LLC, Civil No. 24-2051 (D. Minn. Dec. 9, 2024), Judge Donovan W. Frank found that there is a limit, and that texts sent more than two years after the relationship ended fell outside it.
On this page
A Glitch Brings Back a Former Customer
The plaintiff's cell number had been registered on the National Do Not Call Registry since 2006. In 2020, she signed up for a year of quarterly pest control with Aptive. Her service agreement had an arbitration clause with a class waiver, a 30-day opt-out window she didn't use, and a line saying it survived termination. The agreement also permitted account and appointment messages. A separate "Welcome Checklist" asked for consent to marketing calls and texts, and she didn't check that box.
The relationship ended in January 2021. Then, in June 2023, she got an automated text about setting up autopay. She replied "Stop." In November 2023, a text announced an upcoming appointment. She replied "Stop" again and got another message the same day. A technician texted to inform her that service would occur this morning. When the plaintiff said she hadn't asked for service, the technician apologized and blamed a system glitch that added past customers. More texts and another "Stop" followed, and a representative confirmed that her account had been closed since 2021.
She filed a class action for negligent and willful violations of the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) and invasion of privacy. Aptive moved to compel arbitration.
The Clause Was Valid, but the Claims Were Outside It
The plaintiff didn't dispute that the clause was valid, so the only question was scope. Aptive argued:
- The clause is broad, with no exclusions.
- But for the contract, Aptive wouldn't have had her number.
- The survival clause kept arbitration alive after the agreement ended.
The court rejected each point. The claims were about unsolicited texts sent more than two years after the contract ended to a number on the Do Not Call Registry. They had nothing to do with the services under the agreement. The survival clause would matter if she were suing over the old pest control work, but it can't "sweep in any post-agreement claim" with no connection to the deal. Having her number from the old relationship was only a "tenuous" link.
Aptive also argued that the claims depended on the contract because she relied on the unchecked consent box. The court disagreed. Her rights come from the TCPA, not the consent form she declined to sign.
Contrast This With Adler
In Adler v. American Express, which we covered recently, an Ohio court sent wrong-account robocalls to arbitration. That cardholder's relationship with the bank was ongoing, and he had given the bank the number in connection with his accounts. Here, the relationship had been over for years and the texts came from a system error. Timing and connection made the difference.
Takeaways
- Broad clauses still have edges. Courts look for a real connection to the contract or relationship, not just a historical one.
- Survival clauses aren't time machines. They preserve arbitration for disputes about the old deal, not everything that happens later.
- Purge former customers. A glitch that re-added past customers led to texts, and then a lawsuit that stayed in court.
Read the District of Minnesota memorandum opinion.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
