Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Bell v. Hawx: "Tried to Sell Me Pest Control" Isn't Enough Detail, but Injunctive Standing Survives
Here's a pleading lesson with a twist. In Bell v. Hawx Services, LLC, Case No. 2:24-cv-00825-DC-DMC (E.D. Cal. Sept. 2, 2025), Judge Dena Coggins dismissed a do-not-call claim under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) because the complaint didn't describe what the calls actually said. But the court also held that the plaintiff had standing to seek an injunction, because nothing suggested the company had stopped or deleted his number. The plaintiff got leave to amend.
On this page
Two Calls in One Morning
The plaintiff alleged his cell phone number was on the National Do Not Call Registry and used for personal purposes. On December 4, 2023, at 8:10 a.m., he got a call from someone who said he was with Hawx and "attempted to solicit" him to buy pest control services. He said he wasn't interested and asked not to be called again.
About an hour later, the same number called back with another pest control pitch. When he asked why they were calling again, the caller said he couldn't control it because he was using an autodialer. The plaintiff also alleged that the company didn't scrub its lists against the registry. He filed a putative class action under 47 U.S.C. ยง 227(c)(5).
The Calls Needed More Description
To state a registry claim, a plaintiff must plausibly allege more than one "telephone solicitation," meaning a call made to encourage the purchase of goods or services. The court noted that, under Ninth Circuit precedent, a cell phone used for both personal and business purposes is presumptively residential, so that element was fine.
The problem was content. The complaint said only that the caller "attempted to solicit" the plaintiff "to purchase Hawx's pest control services." Following an Arizona decision that rejected bare allegations that calls were made "for the purpose of soliciting," the court found this too conclusory. A plaintiff doesn't need a "line-by-line transcript," the court said, but needs more than a label. Since the complaint gave no details about what was said on either call, it didn't plausibly show the calls were telephone solicitations.
Injunctive Standing Survived
Hawx argued there was no standing for an injunction because the plaintiff hadn't received any calls since December 4, 2023. The court agreed that the timing and number of the two calls, standing alone, didn't show a likelihood of future harm.
But the plaintiff alleged more. He pointed to the company's apparent lack of scrubbing and its use of a dialer the caller said he couldn't control. Relying on the Ninth Circuit's reasoning in Campbell v. Facebook, the court noted that Hawx hadn't claimed it stopped the conduct or deleted his number. Because Hawx allegedly still had his number, there was a "sufficient likelihood" it could call again. The injunction request stayed.
Leave to Amend
Hawx argued amendment was futile because the plaintiff had already amended once. The court wasn't convinced the claim couldn't be cured and gave him 14 days to amend. It didn't reach Hawx's alternative motion to strike.
Takeaways
- Describe the call. Saying a caller "attempted to solicit" you is a conclusion. Plead what was offered and what was said.
- Retaining a number can support standing. If a company keeps a number after a stop request, a court may find a real risk of future calls.
- Showing you've stopped helps defendants. The court contrasted cases where a company showed it honored the do-not-call request.
Read the Eastern District of California order.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
