Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
St. Louis Heart Center v. Nomax: Eighth Circuit Finds No Standing for Technical Fax Opt-Out Defects, Orders Remand to State Court
A fax recipient that conceded consent and could have opted out using the notice provided lacked Article III standing to sue over technical defects in that notice. In St. Louis Heart Center, Inc. v. Nomax, Inc., No. 17-1794, 899 F.3d 500 (8th Cir. Aug. 6, 2018), the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit agreed the plaintiff lacked standing. But it held that a removed case must go back to state court, not be dismissed with prejudice.
On this page
The bottom line: when a plaintiff concedes consent, harms such as lost paper and toner are not traceable to a defective opt-out notice. And when a federal court lacks jurisdiction over a removed case, 28 U.S.C. § 1447(c) requires remand.
Background
St. Louis Heart Center filed a putative class action in Missouri state court alleging that Nomax, Inc. sent it twelve fax advertisements for a potassium tablet without opt-out notices meeting the requirements of the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) and the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) regulations implementing it. Each fax listed a return fax number for requesting samples. Six had a box to check to stop receiving faxes from Nomax, and six had a "Please do NOT fax to this office" box. Each listed a Nomax contact's name, phone number and email.
Bais Yaakov of Spring Valley v. FCC: The D.C. Circuit Strikes Down the Solicited Fax Rule
The complaint alleged lost paper and toner, tied up phone lines, wasted staff time and invaded privacy. But the Heart Center's president testified the case was "not based upon the fact that consent was not given," and counsel said consent "will not be an issue." He had requested samples of the product at least four times. He also said he never tried to opt out because the notices were not proper.
Nomax removed the case, and the federal district court dismissed the case with prejudice for lack of standing.
The decision
Judge Colloton wrote for the panel, which included Judges Benton and Erickson.
- No traceability. The court assumed the alleged harms could be an injury in fact. But the plaintiff also had to show the injury was fairly traceable to the alleged violation. The district court found the Heart Center "both invited and did not rebuke" the faxes, and that finding was not clearly erroneous. With consent conceded, the faxes would have consumed paper and toner and occupied the line whether or not the opt-out notice was technically compliant.
- No intangible injury from the notice defects. Under Spokeo, a bare procedural violation is not enough without a risk of real harm. The notices gave the recipients the "means and opportunity" to opt out through a checkbox, a domestic fax number and a contact's phone and email. The Heart Center never tried, and there was no evidence that Nomax would have ignored a request. Any technical violation caused no actual harm, and no risk of actual harm.
- Remand, not dismissal. The district court had relied on an earlier circuit decision directing dismissal. The panel explained that later and earlier circuit precedent squarely addressing the removal statute controls: when a removed case lacks an Article III case or controversy, the federal court must remand. State courts are not bound by Article III limits. The court vacated the dismissal with prejudice and directed a return to state court.
Why it matters
Nomax is a reminder that standing defenses in removed cases can send a TCPA claim back to state court rather than end it. Defendants should consider that result before removing and then challenging standing.
Practical takeaways
- Opt-out notices should track fully the FCC's requirements, even though practical functionality was central to the standing analysis here.
- Records of sample requests and other customer interaction can be relevant to consent and traceability.
- Plaintiff concessions about consent may affect the standing analysis.
- Weigh the remand consequence of § 1447(c) before removing and then raising a standing defense.
Read the Eighth Circuit's opinion in St. Louis Heart Center v. Nomax.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
