Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Melito v. Experian Marketing Solutions: Second Circuit Holds Unwanted Text Messages Alone Establish Article III Standing
Receiving unsolicited text messages, without any other harm, is a concrete injury sufficient for Article III standing under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA). In Melito v. Experian Marketing Solutions, Inc., Nos. 17-3277 and 17-3279, 923 F.3d 85 (2d Cir. Apr. 30, 2019), the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit so held, dismissed a nonsettling third-party defendant's appeal for lack of standing to appeal, and affirmed approval of a $14.5 million class settlement.
On this page
The bottom line: in the Second Circuit, TCPA text message plaintiffs "need not allege any additional harm beyond the one Congress has identified."
Background
The plaintiffs alleged that Experian Marketing Solutions, acting for American Eagle Outfitters (AEO), sent spam texts using an automatic telephone dialing system (ATDS) platform built by a nonparty. They alleged no injury beyond receipt of the texts. The district court dismissed the claims against Experian, and AEO then filed a third-party complaint against Experian seeking indemnity and related relief.
AEO and the plaintiffs settled. The Southern District of New York certified a settlement class of roughly 618,289 persons who received AEO texts without appropriate consent. AEO agreed to pay $14,500,000, and notices estimated each claimant could receive between $142 and $285. Experian objected that the plaintiffs lacked standing under Spokeo, Inc. v. Robins. Class member Kara Bowes objected that the settlement was unfair. Ultimately, the district court approved the settlement.
The Fifth Circuit’s single-text standing decision
The decision
Judge Hall wrote for the panel, which included Judge Lynch and District Judge Engelmayer, sitting by designation.
- Experian could not appeal yet. A nonsettling defendant generally lacks standing to challenge a settlement unless it suffers "formal legal prejudice." Experian argued that a third-party defendant may raise the original defendant's defenses under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 14. The court agreed it could, but in the third-party indemnity action, not by blocking AEO's settlement. Because the settlement did not strip Experian of any claim or defense, its appeal was dismissed.
- The court still had to decide standing. Federal courts must satisfy themselves of jurisdiction, so the panel addressed Spokeo, treating Experian's brief as, in effect, an amicus submission.
- Unwanted texts are a concrete injury. The court relied on both factors Spokeo identifies. First, Congress found that unrestricted telemarketing is a "nuisance and privacy invasion," and text messages present the same harms. Second, those harms closely relate to traditional claims for invasion of privacy, intrusion upon seclusion and nuisance. The court followed the Ninth Circuit in Van Patten v. Vertical Fitness Group and the Third Circuit in Susinno v. Work Out World.
The court distinguished Second Circuit decisions such as Katz v. Donna Karan and Strubel v. Comenity Bank, which involved the risk of harm flowing from a statutory violation. Here, by contrast, "the receipt of unwanted advertisements is itself the harm." The court also noted that whether the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) properly extended the TCPA to texts goes to the cause of action, not subject matter jurisdiction. Experian's arguments about ATDS use, revocation and ascertainability went to the merits and were not reached.
- Bowes's objections failed. The court granted the plaintiffs' motion to supplement the record with evidence that they received the texts, so it did not decide whether allegations alone suffice at class certification. It then rejected each settlement challenge under the abuse of discretion standard. The notice was adequate. The district court properly weighed the Grinnell factors given real litigation risks. The release of later claims was valid because those claims arose from the "identical factual predicate." Incentive awards were not barred.
Practical takeaways
- In the Second Circuit, a Spokeo challenge based solely on the absence of extra harm is unlikely to defeat a text message claim.
- Nonsettling third-party defendants should preserve defenses for the indemnity proceeding rather than relying on objections to the main settlement.
- Releases in a settlement can extend to post-settlement conduct on the same factual predicate.
Read the Second Circuit's opinion in Melito v. Experian Marketing Solutions.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- Opinion, Melito v. Experian Marketing Solutions, Inc., Nos. 17-3277 and 17-3279 (2d Cir. decided Apr. 30, 2019)
- Opinion, Melito v. Experian Marketing Solutions, Inc., Nos. 17-3277 and 17-3279 (2d Cir. decided Apr. 30, 2019) (2)
- Opinion, Melito v. Experian Marketing Solutions, Inc., Nos. 17-3277 and 17-3279 (2d Cir. decided Apr. 30, 2019).
