Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Mason v. Bank of America: A State Court Counterclaim Dismissed With Prejudice Bars a Federal Telephone Consumer Protection Act Suit
In Mason v. Bank of America, N.A., No. 26-cv-22095-BLOOM (S.D. Fla. July 8, 2026), Judge Bloom dismissed with prejudice a Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) and Florida Consumer Collection Practices Act (FCCPA) suit on res judicata grounds. The plaintiff had already raised the same claims as counterclaims in a state court collection action, where they were dismissed with prejudice. The order is a reminder that a consumer's choice of forum in collection litigation can determine whether a TCPA claim survives at all.
On this page
Background
The plaintiff alleged that a bank placed autodialed calls to collect a credit card debt and that, after he revoked consent by certified letter on May 24, 2024, he received at least 15 more calls, some filling his voicemail. When the bank sued him in Miami-Dade County Court, he filed pro se counterclaims under the TCPA, the FCCPA and the Florida Telephone Solicitation Act. The first counterclaim was dismissed without prejudice; the amended counterclaim was dismissed with prejudice after he said he wished to pursue the TCPA claim in federal court. The state court found he "will not be able to formulate a claim" under the TCPA and that his facts did not support an FCCPA violation.
He then filed this federal action asserting TCPA, willful TCPA, and FCCPA counts.
The Res Judicata Analysis
Under Eleventh Circuit law, claim preclusion applies when there is (1) a final judgment on the merits, (2) by a court of competent jurisdiction, (3) involving the same parties or their privies, and (4) the same cause of action. The court found each element satisfied.
Final judgment. A dismissal with prejudice is an adjudication on the merits for purposes of res judicata. The court took judicial notice of the state court's orders.
Same parties. Both proceedings involved only the plaintiff and the bank.
Same cause of action. The plaintiff argued that the state court's with-prejudice dismissal was meant to allow refiling in federal court, that his federal FCCPA claim rested on calls rather than mailings, and that he now had call logs and a voicemail recording. The court disagreed. Both actions involved the same debt, the same phone number, the same cease and desist letter, and the same post-revocation calls. Claims that arise from the same nucleus of operative fact, or that could have been raised in the earlier case, are barred. Additional evidence does not create a new cause of action.
Because res judicata cannot be cured by repleading, the court found amendment futile notwithstanding the plaintiff's pro se status.
Practical Implications
For consumers sued in collection actions, asserting TCPA counterclaims has consequences. If the counterclaim is dismissed with prejudice, a later federal suit on the same calls will likely be barred, whatever the litigant's stated intent to refile elsewhere. A party who prefers a federal forum should avoid litigating the claim to a with-prejudice dismissal in state court, or obtain a dismissal expressly without prejudice.
For creditors and collectors, the order confirms that a state court disposition of TCPA counterclaims can foreclose duplicative federal litigation, and that the state court record may be judicially noticed on a motion to dismiss.
Read the Southern District of Florida order in Mason v. Bank of America.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
