Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Ginwright v. Exeter Finance: A Lender's Debt Counterclaim Does Not Belong in a Federal Robocall Suit
A common defense reflex in collection call litigation is to counterclaim for the unpaid debt. In Ginwright v. Exeter Finance Corp., No. TDC-16-0565 (D. Md. Oct. 6, 2016), the District of Maryland dismissed an auto lender's breach of contract counterclaim for lack of jurisdiction, holding it was permissive rather than compulsory, and added that it would decline jurisdiction anyway.
On this page
Background
The borrower financed a vehicle purchase in 2013, and the dealer assigned the contract to the lender. He alleged the lender called his cell phone "hundreds of times" with an automatic dialing system while collecting the debt, continued after he repeatedly told it to stop, and told him the calls would continue. He sued under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) and the Maryland Telephone Consumer Protection Act.
The lender counterclaimed for breach of the financing contract, alleging nonpayment, repossession, and a remaining deficiency after resale. The borrower moved to dismiss for lack of subject matter jurisdiction.
The Fourth Circuit Rule
The counterclaim had no independent federal question or diversity basis, so it depended on supplemental jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1367. Under Fourth Circuit precedent, federal courts have supplemental jurisdiction over compulsory counterclaims but not permissive ones.
The lender argued that § 1367 superseded that rule, citing First, Second, and Seventh Circuit decisions extending supplemental jurisdiction to some permissive counterclaims. The court declined to depart from binding Fourth Circuit precedent, noting that district courts in the circuit continue to follow it and that the Supreme Court has described § 1367 as codifying the prior common nucleus of operative fact standard.
Permissive, Not Compulsory
Applying the Fourth Circuit's four-part inquiry, the court found:
- Different issues. The TCPA claim turns on autodialed calls and consent. The counterclaim turns on nonpayment and possibly whether repossession and resale complied with Maryland's credit statute.
- Different evidence. Call records and dialer testimony on one side; payment history and resale procedures on the other. The contract might bear on consent, but that overlap was limited.
- No preclusion. A judgment on the TCPA claim would not bar a later contract suit, because the claims arise from different core facts.
- A loose logical relationship. The calls might not have happened without the loan, but "there is little or no connection between a claim concerning the misuse of an automatic dialing system and a counterclaim alleging the failure to pay back a loan."
The court relied on Fourth Circuit precedent treating a debt counterclaim to a Truth in Lending Act claim as permissive, and on several district courts reaching the same result in TCPA cases. It found unpersuasive a single contrary California decision applying a different test.
Declining Jurisdiction in Any Event
Even if supplemental jurisdiction existed, the court would decline it under § 1367(c). The fact-intensive contract dispute would likely predominate over the TCPA claim. Public policy also weighed against it: the court quoted Fourth Circuit concern that letting lenders use federal consumer cases to pursue private claims would "impede expeditious enforcement of the federal penalty" and involve federal courts in debt collection matters "having no federal significance."
Takeaways
- Debt counterclaims face a jurisdictional wall in the Fourth Circuit. Absent independent jurisdiction, they will likely be dismissed.
- Elsewhere, the analysis may differ. Circuits applying § 1367 more broadly may allow some permissive counterclaims, though courts can still decline them.
- The contract claim survives elsewhere. As the court explained, a TCPA judgment would not preclude a separate suit on the debt.
Read the court's memorandum opinion.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
