Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Bais Yaakov of Spring Valley v. FCC: The D.C. Circuit Strikes Down the Solicited Fax Rule
In Bais Yaakov of Spring Valley v. Federal Communications Commission, No. 14-1234 (consolidated with twelve related petitions), 852 F.3d 1078 (D.C. Cir. Mar. 31, 2017), the D.C. Circuit held that the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) lacked authority to require opt-out notices on fax advertisements sent with the recipient's permission. The ruling removed a major source of class action exposure under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA), as amended by the Junk Fax Prevention Act of 2005.
On this page
Statutory and Regulatory Background
The Act generally prohibits sending an "unsolicited advertisement" by fax, defined as advertising material sent "without that person's prior express invitation or permission, in writing or otherwise." An exception allows unsolicited fax advertisements to recipients with an established business relationship, provided, among other conditions, the fax contains a compliant opt-out notice. The Act supplies a private right of action with at least $500 per violation.
In 2006, the FCC adopted what the court called the Solicited Fax Rule, requiring opt-out notices even on solicited fax advertisements.
The Petitions
Anda, a generic drug distributor, faxed pricing information to pharmacies, many of which had given permission. Anda was sued in a Missouri class action seeking more than $150 million for faxes lacking compliant opt-out notices, even though many plaintiffs admitted consenting. Anda petitioned the FCC in 2010 seeking a ruling that the Act does not require opt-out notices on solicited faxes. In 2014, the FCC adhered to its interpretation, while waiving the rule for solicited faxes sent before April 30, 2015. Commissioners Pai and O'Rielly dissented in relevant part. Businesses petitioned for review, and other petitioners separately challenged the waivers.
The Majority Opinion
Judge Kavanaugh wrote for the court, joined by Senior Judge Randolph. Applying Chevron, the court found the statutory text clear. Congress drew a line between unsolicited and solicited fax advertisements, requiring opt-out notices only on the former. The court rejected the theory that an agency may act unless Congress prohibits it, explaining that the FCC "may only take action that Congress has authorized."
The court acknowledged that the FCC may reasonably define "prior express invitation or permission" and may allow recipients to revoke permission by request. But it may not require opt-out notices on faxes sent with permission. The agency's policy rationale could not override the text.
The court held the Solicited Fax Rule "unlawful to the extent that it requires opt-out notices on solicited faxes," vacated the 2014 Order and remanded. The waiver petitions were dismissed as moot.
The Dissent
Judge Pillard dissented. In her view, the FCC's authority to implement the ban on unsolicited faxes included requiring opt-out notices on all fax ads, so recipients could limit or withdraw permission. She also would have held that the FCC failed to show good cause for its broad retroactive waivers.
Significance
Because the petitions were consolidated in the D.C. Circuit by the Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation, the Sixth Circuit treated the ruling as binding outside the D.C. Circuit months later in Sandusky Wellness Center v. ASD Specialty Healthcare. As a result:
- Solicited faxes no longer require opt-out notices under federal law.
- Consent evidence becomes central in fax litigation, often defeating class certification.
- Unsolicited faxes relying on an established business relationship must still carry compliant notices.
Read the D.C. Circuit's opinion in Bais Yaakov of Spring Valley v. FCC.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
