Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
True Health v. McKesson: The Ninth Circuit Reopens a Fax Class Action
In True Health Chiropractic, Inc. v. McKesson Corp., No. 16-17123, 896 F.3d 923 (9th Cir. July 17, 2018), the Ninth Circuit partly revived a junk fax class action under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA). The district court had refused to certify any class because McKesson claimed many recipients had agreed to its faxes. The appeals court said that was too broad a brush.
On this page
What happened
True Health Chiropractic and McLaughlin Chiropractic Associates said McKesson faxed them and thousands of other medical practices ads for its software services between September 2009 and May 2010, with no opt-out notice. They also alleged McKesson had received a 2008 citation from the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) warning it about unsolicited fax ads.
McKesson responded that many of those recipients had "prior express invitation or permission." McKesson divided those recipients into three lists. Exhibit A listed 11,979 fax numbers, those who had registered a product or accepted software license agreements. Exhibit B, 2,701 numbers, covered people who checked a fax-preference box, signed consent forms or confirmed by phone. Exhibit C, 55 numbers, covered consent given orally or by email to sales reps. The Northern District of California denied certification saying individual consent issues would predominate.
What the court held
Judge William Fletcher wrote for the panel.
No hidden ascertainability test. The plaintiffs said the trial court imposed an administrative feasibility requirement. The panel disagreed; the order only mentioned the concept in passing.
No opt-out notice for solicited faxes. The plaintiffs argued every fax, consented or not, needed an opt-out notice under the FCC's Solicited Fax Rule. The Ninth Circuit joined the Sixth Circuit and held it was bound by the D.C. Circuit's ruling in Bais Yaakov v. FCC, 852 F.3d 1078 (D.C. Cir. 2017), striking that rule down.
Consent is the defendant's burden. Following Van Patten v. Vertical Fitness Group, 847 F.3d 1037 (9th Cir. 2017), the court ruled that "prior express invitation or permission" was an affirmative defense McKesson must prove. So the court looked only at the consent defenses McKesson actually raised and backed with evidence.
Subclasses. The result split three ways:
- After removing Exhibits B and C, the remaining 9,223 numbers satisfied predominance. The product registrations and license agreements showed little variation, so consent could be decided by reading them.
- The 55 Exhibit C numbers did not. Consent there rested on personal relationships with sales reps.
- Exhibit B went back to the district court to decide in light of Van Patten, along with the Rule 23(a) requirements.
Why this matters
Defendants can't defeat a fax class just by saying "some people consented." They need evidence, and uniform consent documents cut both ways: they're easy to evaluate class-wide.
This litigation didn't end here. Years later the same case reached the Supreme Court, which decided in 2025 that district courts aren't bound by the FCC's interpretations of the TCPA. You can read the Supreme Court's McLaughlin opinion for that chapter.
Practical points
- Keep consent records organized by method, since that's how courts will slice classes.
- Standardized registration or license forms will be examined class-wide.
- Individual sales rep relationships are the kind of consent evidence that can defeat certification.
Read the Ninth Circuit's opinion in True Health v. McKesson.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
