Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Bridging Communities v. Top Flite Financial: Speculative Consent Defenses Do Not Defeat Predominance
In Bridging Communities, Inc. v. Top Flite Financial, Inc., No. 15-1572, 843 F.3d 1119 (6th Cir. Dec. 15, 2016), the Sixth Circuit reversed both the denial of class certification and the dismissal of a junk fax class action under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA). The court held that the bare possibility of individualized consent cannot defeat predominance, and that unaccepted offers of judgment do not moot a plaintiff's claims.
On this page
Background
The case was another arising from Business to Business Solutions (B2B), a fax broadcaster that purchased a list of fax numbers from InfoUSA and sent clients' advertisements to numbers on that list. B2B's operator testified that she did not contact anyone on the list to seek consent.
In March 2006, B2B sent more than 4,000 faxes advertising Top Flite Financial, a Michigan residential mortgage company, offering "0 Down, 0 Closing Costs!" Bridging Communities, a Southwest Detroit nonprofit, and Gamble Plumbing & Heating received the fax and filed class actions, later consolidated, in the Eastern District of Michigan.
The district court denied certification on predominance grounds, reasoning that some recipients might have consented to Top Flite or InfoUSA. Top Flite then made Rule 68 offers of judgment of $1,550 plus costs and an injunction. The plaintiffs let the offers lapse, and the district court dismissed the complaints as moot in April 2015.
The Court's Analysis
Judge Stranch wrote for a panel that included Judges Gilman and White.
Predominance. The plaintiffs offered classwide evidence of no consent: the numbers came from a single purchased list, and B2B never sought consent. Top Flite, by contrast, offered no evidence that any recipient had consented. The court refused to let "speculation and surmise" decide certification, holding that "the mere mention of a defense is not enough to defeat the predominance requirement of Rule 23(b)(3)."
City Select on missing fax logs and certification
The court noted that even when a defendant produces some evidence that a defense applies to some class members, certification is routinely granted because common issues need only predominate. Courts may address such members through subclasses or exclusion. The court distinguished Gene & Gene v. BioPay from the Fifth Circuit, observing that BioPay itself recognized classwide proof of no consent where numbers came from a single purveyor.
Top Flite additionally argued that the person who ordered the faxes worked for a subsidiary. The court noted Top Flite had conceded at oral argument that who qualifies as the "sender" is a common question.
Mootness. The dismissal rested on O'Brien v. Ed Donnelly Enterprises, which the Supreme Court abrogated in Campbell-Ewald Co. v. Gomez while the appeal was pending. Applying the law in effect at decision, the court held an unaccepted offer of judgment is a legal nullity, and does not moot the case.
The court reversed and remanded.
Practical Takeaways
This decision remains significant in junk fax class litigation:
- Defendants asserting consent must come forward with actual evidence, not hypotheses.
- Purchased lists and the broadcaster's failure to verify consent can provide classwide proof of no consent.
- Picking off named plaintiffs with individual offers will not end a putative class action.
The Sixth Circuit later distinguished this decision in Sandusky Wellness Center v. ASD Specialty Healthcare where the defendant had produced voluminous consent documentation.
Read the Sixth Circuit's opinion in Bridging Communities v. Top Flite Financial.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- Opinion, Bridging Communities, Inc. v. Top Flite Financial, Inc., No. 15-1572 (6th Cir. Dec. 15, 2016)
- Opinion, Bridging Communities, Inc. v. Top Flite Financial, Inc., No. 15-1572 (6th Cir. Dec. 15, 2016) (2)
- Opinion, Bridging Communities, Inc. v. Top Flite Financial, Inc., No. 15-1572 (6th Cir. Dec. 15, 2016).
