Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Garcia v. Star Power Marketing: Even an Unopposed Class Certification Motion Must Address Consent
In Garcia v. Star Power Marketing Group, LLC, No. 24-4823 (E.D. Pa. June 24, 2026), Judge Henry denied without prejudice a motion to certify a Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) Do Not Call class, even though the defendant filed no opposition. The opinion is a reminder that Rule 23 requires rigorous analysis regardless of whether a defendant participates, and that a plaintiff cannot rely on the absence of consent evidence alone.
On this page
Background
The plaintiff alleged that her number was on the National Do Not Call Registry and that she received at least five text messages inviting her to events associated with the defendant. She also asserted a claim under the Pennsylvania Telemarketer Registration Act (PTRA). Default was entered early in the case, then set aside by agreement. In its answer, the defendant asserted that the plaintiff's number had opted in to its messages and denied that anyone who opted in to a text database, with the ability to text stop, could be aggrieved.
The plaintiff moved to certify a national Do Not Call class and a Pennsylvania PTRA class. Using texting platform records obtained by subpoena, the plaintiff's counsel identified 2,892 registry numbers that received texts.
Rule 23(a)
Numerosity was easily satisfied. Adequacy of counsel was not contested, and the court saw no barrier to the plaintiff's own adequacy, but her supporting declaration was unsigned and entitled to little weight. The court invited a signed version.
Typicality failed. Given the defendant's opt-in assertions, the court could not determine whether consent was a defense common to the class or a unique defense likely to play a significant role at trial. The class definition did not exclude consenting recipients, and the plaintiff did not show the defendant lacked any consent mechanism.
Rule 23(b)
The court found the Rule 23(b)(2) request underdeveloped. Because the plaintiff sought statutory damages, she needed to explain whether she sought hybrid certification under both (b)(2) and (b)(3), or why damages were merely incidental to injunctive relief.
Ward v. Liberty Mutual on lead-site consent evidence
Predominance also failed. The plaintiff asserted that the defendant had admitted it lacked consent for anyone, but cited no record support, and the answer said the opposite. Citing the Conner v. Fox Rehabilitation Services litigation, affirmed as Steven A. Conner, DPM, P.C. v. Fox Rehabilitation Services, P.C., Nos. 23-1550 & 23-1684 (3d Cir. Jan. 24, 2025), the court noted that individualized consent inquiries can defeat predominance, and that a plaintiff is not entitled to a presumption that class members did not consent. A defendant's failure to produce consent evidence was not enough. If the defendant had stonewalled discovery, the remedy was a motion to compel.
The PTRA Class
The court questioned whether any class could be certified under the PTRA, which courts in the district have repeatedly held provides no private right of action. It ordered supplemental briefing on why that claim should not be dismissed with prejudice.
Practical Implications
For plaintiffs, a silent defendant does not lighten the burden. A renewed motion should address consent affirmatively, through evidence about how the defendant collected numbers, a class definition limited to nonconsenting recipients, or records showing no opt-in mechanism existed. Hybrid certification requests should be explained.
For defendants, the opinion shows that consent allegations in an answer can matter even without an opposition brief. A well-supported renewed motion could still succeed.
Read the Eastern District of Pennsylvania opinion in Garcia v. Star Power Marketing.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
