Case analysis · Calls & text messages
Conner v. Fox Rehabilitation: Third Circuit Rejects First Amendment Challenge to the Junk Fax Ban
In Steven A. Conner, DPM, P.C. v. Fox Rehabilitation Services, P.C., Nos. 23-1550 & 23-1684 (3d Cir. Jan. 24, 2025), a divided Third Circuit panel affirmed a judgment that COVID-era "blast faxes" were unsolicited advertisements, rejected facial and as-applied First Amendment challenges to the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) fax provision, 47 U.S.C. § 227(b)(1)(C), and affirmed denial of class certification. The opinion is not precedential.
On this page
Background
Early in the pandemic, Fox, a home-based rehabilitation provider, ran its first blast fax campaign to reassure referral sources that it was open and following COVID guidelines. Through a vendor, it sent 144,868 faxes to 20,609 numbers over roughly three months. The plaintiff, a podiatrist with no prior contact with Fox, received eight. The faxes promoted Fox's trademarked "Geriatric House Calls" model, and stated in bold capitals that no homebound status, face-to-face visit, or hospitalization was required.
After a bench trial, the district court found all eight faxes were advertisements and entered judgment for the plaintiff. It had earlier denied class certification.
The Faxes Were Advertisements
The panel applied the Third Circuit's objective test, which looks only at the four corners of the fax. The faxes touted a specific model of care as high quality and unique, and carried an embedded profit motive to generate referrals. The court rejected Fox's argument that its "reasonable recipient" language in prior precedent allowed outside context.
Intermediate Scrutiny and the Junk Fax Ban
The court held that Central Hudson intermediate scrutiny governs because the fax ban targets only commercial speech. It rejected the argument that Sorrell, Reed, and the Supreme Court's 2020 robocall decision displaced the commercial speech doctrine. Joining the Eighth and Ninth Circuits, it held the statute constitutional: the government has substantial interests in preventing cost shifting and protecting privacy; the ban directly advances them; and it is narrowly drawn, since it allows faxes with permission or an established business relationship and leaves every other marketing channel open. Overbreadth does not apply to commercial speech.
The as-applied challenge failed too. Adding pandemic information to promotional faxes does not convert them into noncommercial speech.
The court also noted that Fox never gave the Attorney General the notice required for a constitutional challenge, which limited the arguments it could make on appeal.
The Dissent
Judge Matey would have remanded, finding the record too thin to establish a substantial interest today. He questioned whether the concerns about toner, thermal paper, and busy signals from 1991 still apply in 2025.
Class Certification
The panel found the district court misread the class definition on ascertainability, because membership turned on transmission logs marked "successful," not proof of receipt. But it affirmed on predominance. Fox produced declarations from 32 putative class members saying they had provided fax numbers and permitted advertisements, and the court found consent would require individualized inquiry.
Practical Implications
Constitutional challenges to the fax ban remain uphill, though the dissent provides a roadmap for creating a modern factual record. Senders should treat informational faxes that tout a branded service as advertisements. And documented, relationship-based permission can defeat class certification even when liability is established.
Read the Third Circuit's opinion in Conner v. Fox Rehabilitation.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
