Case analysis · Calls & text messages
City Select Auto Sales v. BMW Bank: No Fax Logs Doesn't Automatically Kill a Junk Fax Class
Junk fax class actions often hit a wall when nobody kept a list of who actually got the fax. In City Select Auto Sales Inc. v. BMW Bank of North America Inc., No. 15-3931, 867 F.3d 434 (3d Cir. Aug. 16, 2017), the Third Circuit said a missing fax log isn't automatically fatal. A sender's customer database plus affidavits from recipients may be sufficient.
On this page
The faxes
Creditsmarts runs an online system linking independent car dealers with auto lenders. BMW's up2drive financing division signed up to offer loans through it. In late 2012, a Creditsmarts employee used a fax broadcaster, WestFax, to send faxes with the up2drive logo saying "UpToDrive is looking for your BUSINESS!!" Batches of 5,480, 5,107 and 10,402 faxes went out on three dates.
The recipient lists came from Creditsmarts' customer database. But neither Creditsmarts nor WestFax kept the lists. And the database itself wasn't preserved as it stood in December 2012, only as of February 2014.
City Select, a New Jersey dealer that got one of the faxes, sued under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA). It proposed a class of dealerships in the Creditsmarts database by December 27, 2012, with fax numbers, that were sent the BMW faxes. A magistrate judge denied its request for the database before certification. The District of New Jersey then denied certification on one ground: ascertainability. It found "no objective way of determining which customers were actually sent the BMW fax."
What the Third Circuit held
Judge Scirica wrote the opinion. The court vacated and remanded for two reasons.
Affidavits plus records can work. The Third Circuit requires a class defined by objective criteria and a "reliable and administratively feasible" way to determine membership. Affidavits alone won't do it without records or a way to weed out bad ones. But affidavits combined with the database could. Here the database limits the universe of possible claimants, and the only question is whether a given dealer in it received the fax. That doesn't necessarily require infeasible individual fact-finding. Some over-inclusiveness is acceptable, though a high degree could still prevent certification.
The plaintiff never got to see the database. Without it, the record couldn't support a finding that the class wasn't ascertainable. The court took the unusual step of holding the database must be produced, with a protective order if needed. It also noted circumstantial evidence, including the Creditsmarts CEO's description of the fax as going to its "registered dealer list," suggesting the faxes went to everyone in the database.
The concurrence
Judge Fuentes concurred but urged the circuit to drop its "administrative feasibility" requirement entirely. He pointed out that the Second, Sixth, Seventh and Ninth Circuits had rejected it, and argued it burdens exactly the low-value consumer cases that only work as class actions.
Why this matters
For TCPA fax senders, City Select shows that failing to keep transmission logs isn't a safe harbor in the Third Circuit. Your own customer database may define the class.
Practical points:
- Keep consent records and opt-out compliance, not just fax logs.
- Be aware that your marketing database may be discoverable at class certification.
- Plaintiffs should seek record production early and preserve the issue.
Gorss Motels v. Brigadoon on fax consent evidence
Read the Third Circuit's opinion in City Select Auto Sales v. BMW Bank.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- Opinion, City Select Auto Sales Inc. v. BMW Bank of North America Inc., No. 15-3931 (3d Cir. filed Aug. 16, 2017)
- Opinion, City Select Auto Sales Inc. v. BMW Bank of North America Inc., No. 15-3931 (3d Cir. filed Aug. 16, 2017) (2)
- Opinion, City Select Auto Sales Inc. v. BMW Bank of North America Inc., No. 15-3931 (3d Cir. filed Aug. 16, 2017).
