Case analysis · Calls & text messages
Imhoff Investment v. Alfoccino: The Advertiser Is the Directly Liable Fax "Sender"
In Imhoff Investment, L.L.C. v. Alfoccino, Inc., No. 14-1704, 792 F.3d 627 (6th Cir. July 7, 2015), the Sixth Circuit held that a business whose goods are advertised in a junk fax can be directly liable under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA), even when a third-party broadcaster actually sent the fax. The court also held that a recipient need not have seen or kept the fax to have Article III standing.
On this page
Background
In 2006, Farshid "Tony" Shushtari, who ran marketing for the Alfoccino restaurants, hired the fax broadcaster Business to Business Solutions (B2B) to send 20,000 faxes to local businesses. B2B used a purchased list and did not seek consent from anyone on it. Tony testified that he assumed any broadcaster would do things "the right way."
B2B's records showed the Alfoccino ads were successfully sent 13,980 times to 7,625 unique fax numbers, including twice to Avio, Inc., the substituted class representative. Avio's representative did not remember the faxes and had no copies. The Eastern District of Michigan granted summary judgment to Alfoccino, finding no Article III standing and, alternatively, that Alfoccino could be only vicariously liable and the evidence did not support agency.
The Court's Analysis
Judge Stranch wrote for a panel that included Judges Siler and Moore.
Standing. The court relied on its recent decision in American Copper & Brass v. Lake City Industrial Products, another B2B case, which held that junk faxes impose costs on all recipients by tying up phone lines and fax machines and wasting time. Viewing or printing the fax is unnecessary. The court also cited the Eleventh Circuit's decision in Palm Beach Golf Center-Boca, Inc. v. Sarris, 781 F.3d 1245 (11th Cir. 2015). The expert's analysis of B2B's transmission logs was enough to show Avio received the faxes. And because Alfoccino admitted it paid B2B to send ads, a jury could find their content was advertising.
Direct liability. Federal Communications Commission (FCC) regulations define the fax "sender" as the entity "on whose behalf" an unsolicited advertisement is sent "or whose goods or services are advertised or promoted." Under that definition, direct liability attaches to the advertiser rather than the broadcaster. The broadcaster is liable only in limited circumstances, such as a high degree of involvement.
Paldo Sign on identifying the fax sender
The district court had relied on the FCC's 2013 DISH Network ruling, which applies vicarious liability principles to sellers in the voice call context. The Sixth Circuit held that ruling inapplicable. The voice call rules distinguish between "telemarketers" and "sellers"; the fax rules use "sender." The FCC itself told the Eleventh Circuit in a letter brief that DISH Network did not change the treatment of faxes.
The court rejected Alfoccino's argument that it did not "use" a fax machine, noting that "use" is tied to "send," which the FCC regulation defines. Alfoccino did not challenge the regulation, and such a challenge likely would fail under the Hobbs Act. The court reversed and remanded.
Practical Takeaways
- A business that hires a fax broadcaster bears direct responsibility for the faxes it pays for. Assuming the vendor is compliant is not a defense.
- Broadcaster transmission logs can establish receipt across a class, even when recipients have no memory of the fax.
- The agency analysis used for telemarketing calls does not carry over to fax advertising.
Read the Sixth Circuit's opinion in Imhoff Investment v. Alfoccino.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
