Case analysis · Calls & text messages
Bridgeview Health Care Center v. Clark: You're Liable for the 100 Faxes You Approved, Not the 4,849 Sent
Jerry Clark owned Affordable Digital Hearing, a small hearing aid business in Terre Haute, Indiana. He agreed to try fax advertising, and a fax broadcaster sent his ad far beyond what he authorized. In Bridgeview Health Care Center, Ltd. v. Clark, Nos. 14-3728 and 15-1793, 816 F.3d 935 (7th Cir. Mar. 21, 2016), the Seventh Circuit held he was liable only for the faxes he actually authorized.
On this page
The faxes
In June 2006, a salesman from Business to Business Solutions (B2B) called Clark pitching fax ads. After a follow-up call, Clark agreed to try it. He edited and approved the ad and told B2B to send about 100 faxes to businesses within 20 miles of Terre Haute, for $279. He never saw B2B's fax list.
B2B actually sent 4,849 faxes across Indiana, Illinois and Ohio. Bridgeview Health Care Center, outside Chicago, got one and filed a class action under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA).
The magistrate judge certified a class of all recipients and granted summary judgment for the 32 faxes sent within 20 miles, at $500 each, for a $16,000 judgment. After a bench trial, she found Clark not liable for faxes sent farther away, including Bridgeview's.
What the court held
Judge Manion wrote for the panel, joined by Judges Flaum and Rovner.
DISH Network doesn't apply to faxes. The Federal Communications Commission's (FCC's) 2013 DISH Network ruling dealt with seller liability for third-party telemarketing calls. Regulations define "seller" differently for faxes, so the court held DISH Network inapplicable.
No strict liability. The regulation defines a fax "sender" as the person on whose behalf an ad is sent or whose services are promoted. The court agreed with the trial judge that strict liability for anyone whose goods appear in a fax would be absurd. "The very notion of advertising one's goods entails that one must do something to advertise them."
Agency decides "on whose behalf." The court held that agency rules decide whether a fax was sent on someone's behalf. None applied to the distant faxes:
- Express actual authority: Clark said 100 faxes within 20 miles, and B2B contradicted that.
- Implied actual authority: Nothing about fax marketing inherently calls for blasting thousands of ads across state lines.
- Apparent authority: Clark did nothing toward the recipients suggesting B2B could send faxes for him beyond what he authorized. The ad didn't even mention B2B.
One class was fine. The court rejected Clark's arguments for a subclass and for decertification. All members shared the same interest in the $500 per fax penalty, and the named plaintiff losing at trial didn't wipe out the judgment for those within 20 miles.
The court also voiced concern about how hard these fax cases can hit a small business owner. But it enforced the law as written.
Why this matters
Bridgeview is a key Seventh Circuit case on fax "sender" liability. The Sixth Circuit, in Siding and Insulation Co. v. Alco Vending, declined to adopt its agency-only approach for older faxes.
Practical points:
- Put campaign limits like volume and geography in writing.
- Ask to see the recipient list before anything goes out.
- Know that authorized faxes still create liability without consent or a compliant opt-out notice.
Read the Seventh Circuit's opinion in Bridgeview Health Care Center v. Clark.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- Opinion, Bridgeview Health Care Center, Ltd. v. Clark, Nos. 14-3728 and 15-1793 (7th Cir. Mar. 21, 2016)
- Opinion, Bridgeview Health Care Center, Ltd. v. Clark, Nos. 14-3728 and 15-1793 (7th Cir. Mar. 21, 2016) (2)
- Opinion, Bridgeview Health Care Center, Ltd. v. Clark, Nos. 14-3728 and 15-1793 (7th Cir. Mar. 21, 2016).
