Case analysis · Calls & text messages
Gorss Motels v. Safemark Systems: Franchise Permission, the End of the Solicited Fax Rule and a Call to Revisit Hobbs Act Precedent
Hotels that allowed their franchisor's affiliates to offer purchasing assistance and provided their fax numbers gave the franchisor's approved supplier prior express permission to send fax ads. And since the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) eliminated its solicited fax rule, the supplier faced no liability for missing opt-out notices. In Gorss Motels, Inc. v. Safemark Systems, LP, Nos. 18-12511 and 18-15232, 931 F.3d 1094 (11th Cir. July 26, 2019), the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit affirmed summary judgment for the supplier.
On this page
The bottom line: permission to receive fax ads can be given to a franchisor for its affiliates, and the FCC's elimination of its solicited fax rule abated liability for past violations of that rule.
Background
Gorss Motels, Inc. and E&G, Inc. operated hotels as Wyndham Hotel Group franchisees. Their franchise agreements said Wyndham "may offer optional assistance to [them] with purchasing items used at or in the Facility" and that Wyndham's "affiliates may offer this service on [its] behalf." The hotels provided their fax numbers in the agreements and later forms.
Gorss Motels v. Brigadoon on fax consent evidence
Safemark Systems, an approved supplier of in-room safes, used Wyndham's franchisee database to send a one-page fax in 2013 to 7,402 recipients, with no opt-out notice. In 2015, a Wyndham subsidiary sent a five-page multi-supplier fax, including a Safemark page, to 3,328 recipients. The district court denied class certification and later granted summary judgment to Safemark.
The decision
Judge William Pryor wrote for the panel, joined by Judges Newsom and Branch.
- Express permission, without magic words. The Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) does not define "prior express . . . permission," so the court applied its ordinary meaning: permission "clearly and unmistakably granted by actions or words." By agreeing that affiliates could offer purchasing assistance and supplying fax numbers in the same agreement, the hotels invited advertisements by fax. The court said this was express, not implied, permission.
- More than "mere distribution." The FCC has held that simply publishing a fax number is not permission. The hotels did more. They joined a franchise system, agreed to receive supplier information and listed numbers in a database shared with approved affiliates.
- Permission need not come directly from the recipient to the sender. Nothing in the statute requires that. A recipient may give permission covering third parties.
- Subjective testimony is immaterial. The Gorss president's testimony that no supplier had permission did not create a genuine dispute, given the written agreements, and the hotels never claimed to have revoked permission.
- The solicited fax rule is gone, including for past faxes. After the D.C. Circuit held in Bais Yaakov of Spring Valley v. FCC that the FCC could not require opt-out notices on solicited faxes, the FCC eliminated the rule and dismissed pending waiver petitions, including Safemark's, as moot. The court held that the FCC's rationale, that the rule was unlawful, and its dismissal of the waiver petitions showed an intent to abate liability for past violations. Since the faxes were solicited, no opt-out notices were required.
Having affirmed the summary judgment, the court did not decide the class certification appeal.
The concurrence
All three judges joined a separate opinion by Judge Pryor arguing that the circuit's precedents in Self v. BellSouth Mobility and Mais v. Gulf Coast Collection Bureau misread the Hobbs Act. Their view was that the Act's grant of "exclusive jurisdiction" governed direct review of agency orders but did not require that district courts adopt FCC interpretations during ordinary litigation. They urged the full court to overrule those precedents in an appropriate case.
Practical takeaways
- Franchise and supplier program agreements should clearly state that affiliates and approved vendors can send promotional faxes.
- Maintain records of how and where recipients provided fax numbers.
- Opt-out notices remain required on unsolicited fax ads under the statute, so include them on every fax.
Read the Eleventh Circuit's opinion in Gorss Motels v. Safemark Systems.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- Opinion, Gorss Motels, Inc. v. Safemark Systems, LP, Nos. 18-12511 and 18-15232 (11th Cir. filed July 26, 2019)
- Opinion, Gorss Motels, Inc. v. Safemark Systems, LP, Nos. 18-12511 and 18-15232 (11th Cir. filed July 26, 2019) (2)
- Opinion, Gorss Motels, Inc. v. Safemark Systems, LP, Nos. 18-12511 and 18-15232 (11th Cir. filed July 26, 2019).
