Case analysis · Calls & text messages
Physicians Healthsource v. Cephalon: Leave Your Business Card Out and You Might Have Asked for That Fax
Junk fax cases are the vinyl records of Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) litigation. Old school, still around, still loud. In Physicians Healthsource, Inc. v. Cephalon, Inc., 954 F.3d 615 (3d Cir. 2020), decided March 30, 2020, the Third Circuit held that a medical practice that distributed business cards with its fax number gave express permission for related drug company faxes, and that solicited faxes don't need opt-out notices.
On this page
What happened
Back in 2009, Cephalon sales reps visited Dr. Jose Martinez, a pain management doctor at Physicians Healthsource (PHI), several times. They talked about Cephalon drugs, he got samples of one of them, and the reps sometimes asked if they could follow up and "send [him] things." PHI's business cards, with its fax number, were available to the reps so they could get in touch.
Two faxes then arrived on Cephalon's behalf: an invitation to a dinner program about AMRIX and an invitation to a lunch about FENTORA, both pain drugs he'd already discussed with the reps. Neither had an opt-out notice. PHI filed a putative class action. The Eastern District of Pennsylvania granted summary judgment to the defendants.
What the court decided
Judge Greenaway wrote for the majority.
Handing over a number is express permission. Following its earlier phone call ruling in Daubert v. NRA Group, the court said that voluntarily giving out a number counts as express consent for messages related to why you gave it. PHI conceded it voluntarily provided the fax number.
Advantage Medical v. Electrostim: A Fax Number on a Prescription Form Is Not a License to Advertise
Consent and permission mean the same thing. PHI argued that "express invitation or permission," the fax standard, is stricter than "express consent," the phone call standard. The court disagreed. The statute and the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) use the phrases interchangeably, so the fax standard isn't tougher.
No opt-out notice needed on solicited faxes. The statute only requires opt-out notices on unsolicited faxes. Agreeing with the D.C. Circuit's Bais Yaakov decision, and reaching the same result on its own, the court held that the FCC couldn't require them on solicited ones. The FCC has since abandoned that rule anyway.
The dissent
Judge Porter disagreed hard. He pointed out the cards were basically left in the reception area for anyone to grab, and the doctor testified he never "specifically requested" those two faxes. To him that's implied consent at best, and the statute says express. He also said the established business relationship exception couldn't help, because unsolicited faxes under that exception need an opt-out notice and these had none.
Why it matters
For businesses that build real relationships with customers, this is a friendly ruling in Pennsylvania, New Jersey and Delaware. But a 2-1 split on these facts tells you it's not a sure thing. Different facts, like a bought list, would go differently, which the majority itself noted.
Takeaways
- Get express permission in writing when you can. Don't rely on a card in a lobby.
- Keep faxes tied to what the recipient asked about.
- Include an opt-out notice anyway. It costs nothing and protects you if permission is disputed.
Informational only, not legal advice.
Read the Third Circuit's opinion in Physicians Healthsource v. Cephalon.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
