Case analysis · Calls & text messages
Siding and Insulation Co. v. Alco Vending: The "On Whose Behalf" Standard for Pre-August 2006 Faxes
Who is liable when a fax broadcaster sends unsolicited advertisements promoting another company's services? In Siding and Insulation Co. v. Alco Vending, Inc., No. 15-3551, 822 F.3d 886 (6th Cir. May 9, 2016), the Sixth Circuit held that, for faxes sent before August 1, 2006, liability under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) turns on whether the faxes were sent "on behalf of" the advertiser. That standard sits between strict liability and common law agency.
On this page
Background
Alco Vending is in the business of installing and stocking vending machines. In October 2005, its president accepted an offer from Business to Business Solutions (B2B), a fax broadcaster working with a Romanian company, Macaw. Alco supplied contact information and three selling points, reviewed sample ads and authorized B2B to draw payment from its checking account. A salesman assured Alco the campaign would be "100 percent legal" because B2B had relationships with the recipients. The sample ads stated that Macaw was "solely responsible for its contents and destinations."
B2B sent approximately 7,000 faxes on November 2, 2005 and July 10, 2006. Alco never saw the recipient list. When recipients complained, Alco referred them to B2B, which promised to remove the complaining businesses and later agreed to reimburse Alco for legal costs.
Siding and Insulation, a recipient, filed a putative class action in 2011. The Northern District of Ohio granted Alco summary judgment, applying common law vicarious liability.
The Court's Analysis
Judge Gilman wrote for a panel that included Judges Clay and Griffin. The court examined three possible liability standards.
Strict liability. The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) regulation defining "sender" to include the entity "whose goods or services are advertised or promoted" took effect August 1, 2006. The court held that applying it to earlier faxes would be impermissibly retroactive because it expanded liability beyond the FCC's 1995 "on whose behalf" formulation. The court declined to defer to an FCC letter brief suggesting the definitions were consistent. It distinguished Imhoff Investment v. Alfoccino, where the faxes postdated the regulation.
Paldo Sign on identifying the fax sender
Vicarious liability. The court held the district court erred in relying on the FCC's DISH Network ruling, which addressed telemarketing calls, not faxes. It also respectfully declined to follow the Seventh Circuit's agency-only approach in Bridgeview Health Care Center v. Clark.
On whose behalf. Following the Eleventh Circuit in Palm Beach Golf Center-Boca v. Sarris, the court adopted the 1995 standard as a term of art blending agency principles with policy considerations aimed at the entity most culpable. Relevant factors include input and control over content, approval of the final fax, contractual limits, payment structure, access to recipient lists and steps taken to ensure or cure compliance.
Applying these factors, the court found evidence pointing both ways. Alco lacked access to the list, relied on assurances of legality and acted on complaints. But it supplied selling points, approved the ads, was promoted by them and gained customers. The reasonableness of Alco's reliance on B2B was also relevant. The court reversed and remanded, directing reconsideration of class certification.
Practical Takeaways
- The date of transmission determines which liability standard applies to fax advertisements.
- Advertisers should vet broadcasters and document assurances, list controls and responses to complaints.
- Approval of content weighs toward liability even when a broadcaster disclaims responsibility.
Read the Sixth Circuit's opinion in Siding and Insulation Co. v. Alco Vending.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
