Case analysis · Calls & text messages

Sandusky Wellness Center v. ASD Specialty Healthcare: Consent Evidence and Missing Fax Logs Defeat Certification

The Sixth Circuit's decision in Sandusky Wellness Center, LLC v. ASD Specialty Healthcare, Inc., No. 16-3741, 863 F.3d 460 (6th Cir. July 11, 2017), affirmed the denial of class certification in a junk fax case under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA). Two obstacles proved decisive: concrete evidence that many recipients had consented, and the absence of fax logs identifying who actually received the fax.

By Harrison GevirtzPublished 2 min read
On this page

Background

In 2010, ASD Specialty Healthcare, doing business as Besse Medical, sent a one-page fax advertising the drug Prolia to 53,502 physicians drawn from a list it had purchased from InfoUSA. The broadcaster's invoices showed that 40,343 transmissions, or 75 percent, succeeded. The fax logs identifying which numbers received the fax no longer existed by the time Sandusky Wellness Center, a chiropractic clinic, sued three years later.

Sandusky alleged the fax lacked a compliant opt-out notice and sought to certify a class of all 40,343 recipients. The Northern District of Ohio denied certification, finding that consent and the identity of the class members raised individualized questions.

The Court's Analysis

Judge McKeague wrote for the panel, joined by Judges Suhrheinrich and Sutton. The court reviewed for abuse of discretion and affirmed.

Consent after Bais Yaakov. The district court had relied on a retroactive waiver that the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) granted Besse from the rule requiring opt-out notices on solicited faxes. After that ruling, the D.C. Circuit invalidated the Solicited Fax Rule in Bais Yaakov of Spring Valley v. FCC, 852 F.3d 1078 (D.C. Cir. 2017). The Sixth Circuit held that decision binding outside the D.C. Circuit because the petitions had been consolidated there under the multidistrict procedure. It rejected Sandusky's argument that Besse's separate 2015 waiver order survived, as it too applied the invalidated rule. Thus, Besse could not be liable for recipients who had solicited the fax.

Predominance. Besse produced more than 450,000 pages of customer forms supplying fax numbers, and several thousand intended recipients were current or former customers. Cross-checking these forms against the recipient list would be the driver of the litigation. The court distinguished Bridging Communities v. Top Flite Financial, where the defendant merely speculated about consent. It also rejected the argument that buying a list from a data vendor established classwide lack of consent, and declined to require subclasses based on the consent forms.

Class member identity. With no logs, roughly 13,159 of the intended recipients had no claim, and Sandusky offered no way to remove them. Affidavits recalling a seven-year-old one-page fax would be unreliable. The circuit split over whether this concern belonged to ascertainability, predominance or superiority, and the court declined to resolve it. Even under superiority, denial was within the district court's discretion. The court observed that no circuit had mandated the certification of a TCPA fax class without fax logs, and declined to be the first.

City Select on missing fax logs and certification

Practical Takeaways

This decision demonstrates the role of documentary evidence of consent and record keeping in fax class litigation:

  1. Senders should maintain records showing how each recipient provided a fax number and consented.
  2. Generalized assertions of consent will not suffice; concrete, matched evidence can defeat predominance.
  3. Plaintiffs who delay filing risk losing the transmission records needed for certification.

Read the Sixth Circuit's opinion in Sandusky Wellness Center v. ASD Specialty Healthcare.

Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.

Primary sources

  1. Opinion, Sandusky Wellness Center, LLC v. ASD Specialty Healthcare, Inc., No. 16-3741 (6th Cir. July 11, 2017)
  2. Opinion, Sandusky Wellness Center, LLC v. ASD Specialty Healthcare, Inc., No. 16-3741 (6th Cir. July 11, 2017) (2)
  3. Opinion, Sandusky Wellness Center, LLC v. ASD Specialty Healthcare, Inc., No. 16-3741 (6th Cir. July 11, 2017).
Harrison Gevirtz, Chief Strategy Officer of Ringba, Las Vegas, Nevada

About the Author: Harrison Gevirtz

Harrison Gevirtz serves as the Chief Strategy Officer (CSO) of Ringba, a call tracking and pay per call platform, and is based in Las Vegas, Nevada. Harrison Gevirtz is a serial operator in call tracking, call routing and telemarketing operations, and for the past several years he has focused on how federal regulations affect the daily operations of these industries. At TCPA.com, Harrison Gevirtz covers TCPA litigation, Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR) enforcement, tech support fraud prosecutions and Federal Communications Commission (FCC) rulemaking in a way that's accessible to the non-lawyer executive or compliance manager.

More from Harrison Gevirtz

Topics