Case analysis · Calls & text messages
Bruce Katz, M.D., P.C. v. Focus Forward: Second Circuit Says a Paid Survey Fax Is Not an Ad
Here's a fun one: a fax offering you money to answer survey questions isn't advertising anything. In Bruce Katz, M.D., P.C. v. Focus Forward, LLC, No. 21-1224-cv (2d Cir. Jan. 6, 2022), a per curiam panel of Judges Cabranes, Lohier, and Lee held that an unsolicited faxed invitation to join a market research survey for pay is not an "unsolicited advertisement" under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA). That puts the Second Circuit at odds with the Third Circuit.
On this page
The Faxes
The plaintiff is a medical professional corporation doing business as Juva Skin and Laser Center. Focus Forward is a market research company paid by clients for the information it gathers. In September and October 2019, it sent the practice two faxes, one addressed to "Nurse Practitioners" and one to "Nurses & Physician Assistants." Each said Focus Forward was "currently conducting a market research study" and offered "an honorarium of $150" for a telephone interview.
The practice filed a putative class action. Judge Paul A. Crotty of the Southern District of New York dismissed it, and the Second Circuit affirmed.
The Split
The TCPA, as amended by the Junk Fax Prevention Act of 2005, bans faxing an "unsolicited advertisement," defined as material "advertising the commercial availability or quality of any property, goods, or services."
In Fischbein v. Olson Research Group (2020), a divided Third Circuit panel held that offering payment for survey participation is a commercial transaction, so a fax highlighting it is an ad. The practice asked the Second Circuit to follow Fischbein. Several district courts had gone the other way, including a magistrate judge's recommendation in Machonis v. Universal Survey Center.
Why the Second Circuit Disagreed
- Money isn't "property" here. The word "property" also appears in the TCPA's definition of "telephone solicitation," which covers encouraging "the purchase or rental of, or investment in" property. It would be strange to talk about purchasing or renting money, and identical words in the same statute are presumed to mean the same thing. Both the Fischbein majority and dissent agreed on this point.
- The recipient's participation isn't an available "service." The fax seeks something from the recipient. The sender doesn't even know whether that participation is available. Quoting the Fischbein dissent, such faxes communicate "the exact opposite of availability."
- "Commercial transaction" isn't the test. The panel said Fischbein effectively rewrote the statute to cover advertising "an opportunity" to exchange goods or services.
- History and the regulators agree. A 1991 House report said "telephone solicitation" was not meant to cover market surveys. The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) excluded market surveys in 1992 rules. Its 2006 rule targets surveys "that serve as a pretext to an advertisement," implying not all surveys are pretexts.
No Pretext Here
Following its earlier decision on free-event faxes in Physicians Healthsource v. Boehringer Ingelheim, the court said plaintiffs don't need to plead specific products that would be promoted. But nothing in these faxes suggested pretext, and the practice didn't argue it. The court also cautioned that it wasn't saying any communication offering money escapes the statute. A survey fax offering both money and services might be different.
Takeaways
- In the Second Circuit, a bare paid survey invitation is not a fax ad.
- In the Third Circuit, under Fischbein, the answer may differ.
- Pretext remains the open door. A survey that leads into a pitch is a different case.
Read the Second Circuit opinion.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
