Analysis · Calls & text messages
Schwanke v. SimonMed Imaging: Faxing Imaging Specials and Symposium Invites to a Chiropractor Can Be Advertising
Junk fax cases are still alive, and Schwanke v. SimonMed Imaging LLC, No. CV-25-01759-PHX-DGC (D. Ariz. Oct. 27, 2025), shows why. A Florida chiropractor received faxes from a medical imaging company advertising mammogram specials and inviting him to symposia. The company said none of it was advertising aimed at him. The court disagreed and denied the motion to dismiss.
On this page
The Faxes
Between September 2024 and January 2025, the chiropractor received at least seven faxes he never asked for. Some invited him to symposia where the company would present its services; one offered a 25% early bird discount code. Others announced specials: $99 3D screening mammograms, cardiac imaging for a few hundred dollars, a $50 self pay price, and same day appointments. None included an opt-out notice. He filed a class action under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA), which bans unsolicited fax advertisements absent an established business relationship.
The company didn't dispute the faxes were unsolicited or that there was no business relationship. Its only argument was that they weren't "advertisements."
Symposium Invites: Not "Only Information"
The company leaned on Federal Communications Commission (FCC) guidance that a fax containing only information, like industry news or legislative updates, isn't covered. The court noted that after McLaughlin Chiropractic Associates v. McKesson, district courts aren't bound by the FCC's reading, but said the guidance didn't help anyway. These faxes didn't just inform; they asked him to come ("Please join us"), and one dangled a discount. That could reasonably be a pretext for marketing services that are for sale.
The company compared its faxes to a Ninth Circuit case about a conference invite to present a "Leadership Award." That award wasn't for sale. Imaging services are.
Price Specials: Advertising Doesn't Need to Target the Recipient
The company's second argument was creative: the pricing faxes were aimed at patients, not at the chiropractor, so they weren't trying to sell him anything. It cited a Third Circuit test asking whether the fax gives the impression that a seller is trying to make a sale to the recipient. It also argued mammogram and heart imaging faxes to a chiropractor couldn't benefit the company.
The court wasn't persuaded. The statute defines an advertisement as material advertising the "commercial availability" of goods or services. It doesn't require that the recipient be the buyer, or even an ideal audience. These faxes plainly advertised availability and pricing. Applying the Ninth Circuit's "measure of common sense" from Chesbro v. Best Buy Stores, the court said the faxes "quite clearly" sought patient business by getting the chiropractor's endorsement. It also declined to rely on out-of-circuit precedent the company cited about ancillary economic benefits.
Faxing Someone Else's Coupons? Sixth Circuit Says That Can Still Be an Ad
What It Means
- Referral marketing by fax is risky. Promoting services to providers who might refer patients still advertises commercial availability.
- Event invites can count. Asking the recipient to attend or a discount moves a fax beyond "only information."
- Circuit matters. In the Ninth Circuit, the "is this seller trying to sell to me?" test didn't carry the day.
- Opt-out notices. The missing opt-out claim wasn't challenged, so it moves forward too.
Read the District of Arizona order.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
