Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Faxing Someone Else's Coupons? Sixth Circuit Says That Can Still Be an Ad
Look, I get it. Nobody thinks about fax machines anymore.
On this page
But dentists do. And one Michigan dentist has spent years educating the Sixth Circuit as to what constitutes an illegal fax ad. The court even said so, noting that he "has singlehandedly helped define the contours of TCPA liability in our circuit."
His latest win? A ruling that a company can be on the hook for faxing ads for products it doesn't even sell.
So what happened?
Dr. Brian Lyngaas's dental practice was part of United Concordia Companies, Inc.'s (UCCI) dental network. UCCI's "Value Add Program" allowed network dentists to get discounts from outside vendors. According to the opinion, UCCI negotiated exclusive deals with those vendors and agreed to promote their products.
Between October 2020 and May 2021, UCCI faxed three promos: a 10% discount on personal protective equipment from Prophy Magic, recycling buckets from Dental Recycling North America and student loan refinancing from GradFin.
Lyngaas filed a class action under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA), which bars sending an "unsolicited advertisement" by fax. 47 U.S.C. ยง 227(b)(1)(C). The district court sided with UCCI. It said UCCI's profit motive was too remote, since it wasn't selling the products.
The ruling
In Brian J. Lyngaas, D.D.S., P.L.L.C. v. United Concordia Companies, Inc., No. 24-1777, 140 F.4th 749 (6th Cir. June 9, 2025), the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit reversed. Judge Ritz wrote the opinion.
Here's the thing ... the court said the faxes were ads because:
- They were promotional on their face. They touted brands and discounts, like Prophy Magic being "a direct provider of superior products."
- UCCI had a direct profit aim. It sent the faxes as part of negotiated marketing deals. The court said UCCI "has provided no profit-neutral explanation" for that bargain.
- Senders, not sellers, are liable. Sixth Circuit cases put fax liability on whoever sends the fax. So a sender can be liable for advertising products it doesn't sell, at least if it has a financial interest in the deal.
The court did leave room for the "altruistic coupon-clipper" who faxes deals with no financial angle at all. That case "would be distinguishable."
One catch: Lyngaas couldn't prove he got the GradFin fax, so that one's out. The other two are back to the district court.
Judge Batchelder concurred. She'd go further and drop the sender profit-motive test entirely. To her, a fax is an ad if it promotes the sale of goods "so that some entity can profit."
Why should you care?
If you run a partner program, a perks program or co-marketing of any kind, this one's for you. Pushing your partners' offers to your customers is still advertising. Maybe you can relate.
What to do this week
- Treat partner promos as your ads. Same consent rules apply.
- Get prior express invitation or permission before faxing anything promotional.
- Include a proper opt-out notice on every fax ad.
- Check your co-marketing contracts. If you promised to promote someone, you're advertising.
It's all just simple math. Promote it and you own it. That's it.
Read the Sixth Circuit's opinion in Lyngaas v. United Concordia.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- Opinion, Brian J. Lyngaas, D.D.S., P.L.L.C. v. United Concordia Companies, Inc., No. 24-1777 (6th Cir. decided June 9, 2025)
- Opinion, Brian J. Lyngaas, D.D.S., P.L.L.C. v. United Concordia Companies, Inc., No. 24-1777 (6th Cir. decided June 9, 2025) (2)
- Opinion, Brian J. Lyngaas, D.D.S., P.L.L.C. v. United Concordia Companies, Inc., No. 24-1777 (6th Cir. decided June 9, 2025).
