Case analysis · Calls & text messages

Mauthe v. Optum: A Fax Asking a Doctor to Update Database Info Isn't an Ad, Even if the Sender Profits

Here's a question that comes up more than you'd think: if a company sends a fax that doesn't sell you anything, but the company makes money off the information you send back, is that fax an "advertisement" under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA)? The Third Circuit answered no in Robert W. Mauthe, M.D., P.C. v. Optum, Inc., No. 18-2894, 925 F.3d 129 (3d Cir. May 28, 2019), and it laid out a test for when a fax can count as an ad even though the recipient isn't the buyer.

By Adam YoungPublished 3 min read
On this page

What happened

Optum and OptumInsight run a national database of healthcare providers. They license it to health care, insurance and pharmaceutical companies, who use it for provider directories, network recruiting and claims processing. To keep the data accurate, Optum faxes providers and asks them to verify their practice information.

The fax Dr. Mauthe's practice got said there was "no cost to you to participate in this data maintenance initiative. This is not an attempt to sell you anything." Mauthe sued anyway, on behalf of a putative class, plus a state law conversion claim. The Eastern District of Pennsylvania granted summary judgment to Optum and declined to retain the state claim.

Mauthe's theory

Mauthe didn't claim he was a potential buyer of Optum's database. His argument was that Optum had a profit motive: better data means a more valuable product, so the fax should count as an ad.

The court, in an opinion by Judge Greenberg joined by Judges Ambro and Restrepo, agreed with the facts but not the conclusion. As it put it, "a fax does not become an advertisement merely because the sender intended it to enhance the quality of its products or services and thus its profits." Pretty much everything a business does has a profit motive.

Sandusky Wellness v. Medco: Formulary Faxes Aren't Ads

The test for "third-party based liability"

The court had heard a companion case, Mauthe v. National Imaging Associates, No. 18-2119 (3d Cir. Apr. 17, 2019), which set the standard for faxes sent to potential direct buyers. This case asked about faxes aimed at influencing someone else's purchase. Think of a fax urging a doctor to prescribe a drug that the patient will buy.

To win on that theory, a plaintiff must show the fax:

  1. sought to promote or enhance the quality or quantity of a product or service being sold commercially;
  2. was reasonably calculated to increase the sender's profits; and
  3. directly or indirectly encouraged the recipient to influence the purchasing decisions of a third party.

The key is a "nexus" between the fax and somebody's purchasing decision. The court pointed out that the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) treats calls for pure market research or polling as outside the telemarketing rules, and it didn't want a fax rule that would sweep in research faxes or even a reference check sent on company letterhead.

Optum's fax met the first two prongs but failed the third. It didn't try to influence anyone's purchase, Mauthe's or a third party's.

The pretext argument

The district court also rejected the idea that the fax was a pretext for future marketing. The Third Circuit noted it hasn't endorsed the pretext theory, but said the claim fails anyway because there was no evidence Optum planned to send Mauthe any ads. A future verification fax with similar content wouldn't be an ad either.

With the federal claim gone, it was fine for the district court to dismiss the state conversion claim without prejudice.

Why this matters

If you send informational or data verification faxes, Mauthe is helpful in the Third Circuit. But the test leaves room for liability when a "free" fax nudges the recipient toward a purchase.

Some practical points:

  1. Keep verification faxes strictly informational. No product pitches, pricing or promos.
  2. A clear "this is not an attempt to sell you anything" statement helped here, but the content has to match it.
  3. Don't use verification outreach to set up a later marketing fax.
  4. Remember other circuits apply their own tests to informational faxes.

Read the Third Circuit's opinion in Mauthe v. Optum.

Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.

Primary sources

  1. Opinion, Robert W. Mauthe, M.D., P.C. v. Optum, Inc., No. 18-2894 (3d Cir. filed May 28, 2019)
  2. Opinion, Robert W. Mauthe, M.D., P.C. v. Optum, Inc., No. 18-2894 (3d Cir. filed May 28, 2019) (2)
  3. Opinion, Robert W. Mauthe, M.D., P.C. v. Optum, Inc., No. 18-2894 (3d Cir. filed May 28, 2019).
Adam Young, CEO of Ringba, Miami, Florida

About the Author: Adam Young

Adam Young is a 42-year-old entrepreneur from Miami, Florida. He is the CEO of Ringba, a call tracking and pay per call platform. Adam Young has been in telecom, call routing and performance marketing for over a decade, and is the author of The Pay Per Call Revolution. At TCPA.com, Adam Young writes about the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA), robocall enforcement, tech support fraud cases and what actions by the Department of Justice (DOJ), Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and Federal Communications Commission (FCC) mean for companies that make calls. His goal is to help companies stay compliant and keep scammers off the phone network.

More from Adam Young

Topics