Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
True Health v. McKesson on Remand: After a Supreme Court Win, the Fax Class Still Comes Up Empty
Some lawsuits are marathons. Filed in 2013, True Health Chiropractic, Inc. v. McKesson Corporation, No. 13-cv-02219-HSG (N.D. Cal. May 22, 2026), came back to Judge Haywood S. Gilliam, Jr. after the plaintiffs won at the Supreme Court. On remand, they asked to certify a class again. The court said no.
On this page
How We Got Here
The plaintiffs are claiming they received unsolicited fax advertisements in violation of the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA). This is a later, separate stage from the Ninth Circuit's 2018 decision in the same case, True Health Chiropractic, Inc. v. McKesson Corp., 896 F.3d 923 (9th Cir. 2018). That appeal was about consent: whether questions about which recipients agreed to the faxes defeated class treatment. This 2026 order addresses a different issue: what type of device the fax was sent to. After the 2018 remand, the court certified a renewed class in 2019. Then the Federal Communications Commission's Consumer and Governmental Affairs Bureau issued its Amerifactors ruling, which said online fax services are not "telephone facsimile machines." Bound by that ruling at the time, the court split the class, granted summary judgment against the online fax group, and later decertified the stand-alone fax machine group because nobody could figure out, class-wide, who got the faxes on which kind of device.
Then came McLaughlin Chiropractic Associates v. McKesson Corp., 606 U.S. 146 (2025) in which the Supreme Court held that district courts are not bound by the agency's interpretation of the law in enforcement cases. That sent the big question back down: is an online fax service a telephone facsimile machine?
The Answer: Not a Machine
The junk fax ban covers sending from a fax machine, a computer, or another device, but only receiving on a "telephone facsimile machine." Congress listed computers as sending devices and left them off the receiving side. The plaintiffs argued that a cloud fax server, plus an internet connection, plus some printer somewhere, adds up to "equipment" with the "capacity" to print. The court found that theory nearly limitless. It would erase the difference between a "machine" and a "system."
The court sided with the Fourth Circuit in Career Counseling, Inc. v. AmeriFactors Financial Group, LLC, 91 F.4th 202 (4th Cir. 2024), and with the dissent in the Sixth Circuit's split decision in Lyngaas v. Curaden AG, No. 20-1243 (6th Cir. Mar. 24, 2021), rather than with the majority.
History and the Agency Chime In
The 1991 House Report pointed the same way. Congress worried about wasted paper and toner and about fax lines being tied up. Online fax services cause neither problem. Giving the agency "appropriate respect," the court found Amerifactors more convincing than the earlier 2003 and 2015 orders.
Why the Class Failed
Nobody disputed that there was no class-wide way to sort online fax recipients from stand-alone fax recipients. Once online fax services were out, individual questions dominated and a class action was not the superior method.
Takeaways
- Winning at the Supreme Court gave these plaintiffs a fresh look, not a win. A district court weighing an agency ruling on its own can still agree with it.
- In fax cases, how members of a class received the fax is driving the certification.
- With the Fourth Circuit and this court on one side and a Sixth Circuit majority on the other, where you file still matters.
Read the Northern District of California order denying renewed class certification.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- Order Denying Second Renewed Motion for Class Certification, True Health Chiropractic, Inc. v. McKesson Corporation, No. 13-cv-02219-HSG (N.D. Cal. May 22, 2026)
- True Health Chiropractic, Inc. v. McKesson Corp., 896 F.3d 923 (9th Cir. 2018)
- Career Counseling, Inc. v. AmeriFactors Financial Group, LLC, 91 F.4th 202 (4th Cir. 2024)
- Lyngaas v. Curaden AG, No. 20-1243 (6th Cir. Mar. 24, 2021)
- Order Denying Second Renewed Motion for Class Certification, True Health Chiropractic, Inc. v. McKesson Corporation, No. 13-cv-02219-HSG (N.D. Cal. May 22, 2026).
