Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Lindenbaum v. Realgy: The Sixth Circuit Says Robocalls From 2015 to 2020 Still Count
Here's a fun one from the "nice try" file. In Lindenbaum v. Realgy, LLC, 13 F.4th 524 (6th Cir. 2021), decided September 9, 2021, the Sixth Circuit rejected the argument that the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) robocall ban was unenforceable for five years because of a bad 2015 amendment.
On this page
The backstory
In 2015, Congress added an exception to the robocall ban for calls made "solely to collect a debt owed to or guaranteed by the United States." In 2020, the Supreme Court said that exception was unconstitutional content discrimination, but it cut the exception out and left the rest of the ban standing.
A footnote from three justices mused about liability for calls made while the exception was on the books. Defendants ran with it. Their theory: if the ban was unconstitutional from 2015 to 2020, then nobody could be sued for robocalls made in that window.
Roberta Lindenbaum got two robocalls from Realgy, an electricity company, in late 2019 and early 2020. Realgy moved to dismiss, and the Northern District of Ohio agreed, calling the ban "void" for that period. The United States jumped in on her side to defend its statute.
What the Sixth Circuit said
Judge Bush wrote for the panel, and he opened with a line worth framing: "Courts do not rewrite, amend, or strike down statutes."
Severability is interpretation. An unconstitutional provision is not law at all. So when a court cuts it out, it is explaining what the statute has meant all along without the bad part. That means the decision applies backward, like any other judicial decision.
Not a remedy. Remedies are injunctions, declarations or damages. The Supreme Court's severability ruling gave the challengers none of what they asked for, which shows it wasn't a remedy at all.
The footnote didn't bind anyone. Only three justices joined it.
No First Amendment problem. Realgy argued that if government debt collectors get a fair notice defense and it doesn't, that recreates the same discrimination. The court said fair notice is a neutral due process rule, not a speech restriction. It didn't decide whether debt collectors actually have that defense.
The court treated the dismissal as one for failure to state a claim and reversed.
Why it matters
This shut the door, at least in Ohio, Michigan, Kentucky and Tennessee, on a defense that briefly looked like a get out of jail free card for five years of robocalls. If you made prerecorded or autodialed calls in that window, the ban applied the whole time.
Takeaways
- Don't build a defense around a plurality footnote.
- The robocall ban was enforceable between 2015 and 2020 for ordinary marketing calls.
- Fair notice arguments, if any, are about what a caller reasonably believed the statute allowed.
Informational only, not legal advice.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
