Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Apodaca v. City of Albuquerque: A City Is Not a "Person" Under the Robocall Law, So Its Town Hall Calls Are Off the Hook
Can you sue city hall for robocalls? In Apodaca v. City of Albuquerque, No. CIV 24-1240 (D.N.M. Mar. 30, 2026), the answer was no. The court held that a city is not a "person" under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA), so the statute doesn't reach it at all. The case was dismissed with prejudice.
On this page
The Calls
For years, Albuquerque used a contractor and a calling platform to send prerecorded calls inviting residents to virtual telephone town halls. The city picked the content, the timing and the numbers, which came from its 311 call center, data firms and other sources. Three residents claimed to have received these calls on their cell phones in 2023 and 2024 without ever consenting, and filed a class action.
One of the three had already sued over earlier, pandemic-era town hall calls. The Tenth Circuit ruled against him in 2025 because those calls fell within the emergency exception. It expressly skipped the question of whether a city is a "person." This case picked that question up.
The Federal Communications Commission Said Yes. The Court Said No.
In a 2020 ruling, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) concluded that local governments are "persons" under the TCPA, although state governments are not. The plaintiffs argued the court was bound by that ruling. The court disagreed. After the Supreme Court's 2025 decision in McLaughlin Chiropractic Associates v. McKesson, district courts must decide for themselves what the statute means, giving the agency only "appropriate respect."
Here is the key move. The TCPA borrows its definition of "person" from the Communications Act: "an individual, partnership, association, joint-stock company, trust, or corporation." Because Congress wrote a definition, the court said the familiar rule that cities count as "persons" under civil rights statutes doesn't apply. The question was whether "corporation" in that list includes a city.
The court said it doesn't, for these reasons:
- The company it keeps. Every other item on the list is a private, non-governmental entity, so "corporation" means a private corporation.
- "Person or entity." The TCPA's private right of action lets a "person or entity" sue. If "person" already included governments, "entity" would say nothing.
- The rest of the Communications Act. Another section separately lists "any person, any body politic, or municipal organization."
- Other statutes. When Congress wants municipalities covered, it often names them alongside corporations.
- Purpose. Congress was concerned with commercial telemarketing, not with cities informing their residents.
The court also wasn't persuaded by the FCC's point that Congress swapped a proposed exemption for government calls for the emergency exception. Congress never said it made that change because the law applies to cities.
No Deference Either
Even if the text were unclear, the court said it would not defer to the FCC. Deciding what "person" means is legal interpretation, not technical expertise. The court found the FCC's reasoning flawed because it started from the general presumption about "persons" instead of the definition Congress actually wrote. The court acknowledged that the FCC had been consistent and thorough since 2016, but that wasn't enough.
Why It Matters
- Agency rulings are up for grabs. This is McLaughlin in action: a long-standing FCC interpretation was set aside by a single district court.
- Contractors are a different question. The FCC treats government contractors as "persons," and this ruling addressed only the city itself.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
