Case analysis · Litigation & decisions

Zaller v. Pharmawest Pharmacy: No Private Claim for Missing Date and Time Stamps on Fax Ads

The Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) gives private plaintiffs a damages remedy for unsolicited fax advertisements. It does not give them a separate remedy for every technical defect in a fax. In Dr. Stuart T. Zaller, LLC v. Pharmawest Pharmacy, Ltd., No. CCB-11-789 (D. Md. Nov. 8, 2011), Judge Catherine C. Blake dismissed a standalone count for missing date and time markings while allowing the core federal and Maryland Telephone Consumer Protection Act claims to proceed.

By Harrison GevirtzPublished 2 min read
On this page

Background

The plaintiff alleged it received at least ninety unsolicited faxes advertising drugs and services available at a pharmacy website. It alleged the faxes lacked proper opt-out notices and that some also failed to show the date and time sent. It sued the pharmacy and an unnamed fax broadcaster.

The complaint had four counts: TCPA damages for the unsolicited faxes, TCPA injunctive relief, separate TCPA damages for the missing date and time, and damages under the Maryland statute.

No Private Right of Action Under Section 227(d)

Section 227(b), which bars unsolicited fax advertisements, contains an express private right of action in § 227(b)(3). Section 227(d), the "technical and procedural standards" provision requiring faxes to be marked with the date and time, contains no parallel right. The court noted that courts addressing the question have concluded that § 227(d) may be enforced only by state attorneys general.

The plaintiff argued that the Junk Fax Prevention Act of 2005 changed this. That Act codified the established business relationship exception and required qualifying faxes to carry a notice meeting requirements that include compliance with § 227(d). The plaintiff contended this cross-reference created a separately actionable § 227(b) violation.

The court disagreed, holding that the argument "would require ignoring the plain meaning of the statute." Section 227(b) makes sending a fax unlawful "unless" listed conditions are met. The reference to § 227(d) simply describes one condition of the newly codified exception. It was part of an effort to limit liability, not to create a new cause of action. The court dismissed the date and time count.

The Remaining Claims Were Adequately Pleaded

The pharmacy argued that the complaint never plausibly alleged it sent the faxes. The court found otherwise. The complaint alleged that the defendants sent the faxes and were the "senders," that the advertised website was the defendant's, and that the website listed the defendant's suite address in British Columbia. The attached fax showed the same address, down to the suite number. That was enough to make the claim plausible.

The court also rejected the argument that plural references to "Defendants" failed to give notice. The complaint merely alleged that both defendants engaged in the conduct. Two other points rounded out the analysis:

  • Knowledge of the TCPA is relevant only to treble damages, not to the prima facie claim.
  • The absence of an established business relationship need not be pleaded. Its existence is an affirmative defense.

Sanctions Denied

Because the motion to dismiss succeeded on the date and time count, the court denied the plaintiff's Rule 11 sanctions motion against the defendant and its counsel.

Takeaways

  • Plead fax claims under § 227(b). Date and time marking defects do not support an independent private claim.
  • The 2005 cross-reference limits liability. It defines an exception rather than creating a new violation.

Read the full District of Maryland opinion.

Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.

Primary sources

  1. Memorandum, Dr. Stuart T. Zaller, LLC v. Pharmawest Pharmacy, Ltd., No. CCB-11-789 (D. Md. Nov. 8, 2011)
  2. Memorandum, Dr. Stuart T. Zaller, LLC v. Pharmawest Pharmacy, Ltd. (D. Md. Nov. 8, 2011).
Harrison Gevirtz, Chief Strategy Officer of Ringba, Las Vegas, Nevada

About the Author: Harrison Gevirtz

Harrison Gevirtz serves as the Chief Strategy Officer (CSO) of Ringba, a call tracking and pay per call platform, and is based in Las Vegas, Nevada. Harrison Gevirtz is a serial operator in call tracking, call routing and telemarketing operations, and for the past several years he has focused on how federal regulations affect the daily operations of these industries. At TCPA.com, Harrison Gevirtz covers TCPA litigation, Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR) enforcement, tech support fraud prosecutions and Federal Communications Commission (FCC) rulemaking in a way that's accessible to the non-lawyer executive or compliance manager.

More from Harrison Gevirtz

Topics