Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Oklahoma v. Pope: Before You Attack a Federal Robocall Law, Tell the United States Attorney General
Here's a procedural trap that ensnared the parties and the trial court: In Oklahoma ex rel. Edmondson v. Pope, 516 F.3d 1214 (10th Cir. 2008), a defendant challenged part of the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) under the First Amendment. Nobody told the United States Attorney General. The Tenth Circuit sent the whole thing back so someone would.
On this page
Judge McConnell wrote the opinion.
The Challenge
The Oklahoma Attorney General filed an enforcement action under the TCPA. The defendant challenged the statute's identification requirement for prerecorded calls.
Under 47 U.S.C. § 227(d)(3)(A), the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) must require that all artificial or prerecorded telephone messages:
- state clearly, at the beginning, the identity of the business, individual, or other entity initiating the call; and
- state clearly, during or after the message, that caller's telephone number or address.
The FCC adopted that rule at 47 C.F.R. § 64.1200(b). The defendant argued that forcing callers to identify themselves violated his First Amendment right to speak anonymously.
The Missing Notice
Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 5.1 requires a party challenging the constitutionality of a federal statute to notify the United States Attorney General. And 28 U.S.C. § 2403(a) requires the court to certify the challenge to the Attorney General too. Once notified, the Attorney General can intervene and present evidence.
The defendant and the district court both failed to comply. At oral argument, the court noted, neither party seemed aware the requirement existed.
The state had notified the FCC that it was bringing a TCPA enforcement action, as 47 U.S.C. § 227(f)(1) requires. But the court explained that this is a separate obligation, and it doesn't replace notice to the Attorney General when a statute's constitutionality is challenged.
Why Not Just Notify Him Now?
Appellate courts have options when notice is missed. Sometimes it's enough to notify the Attorney General and let him weigh in on appeal. Here, the Tenth Circuit thought a remand fit better.
Why? Several arguments had been waived or abandoned along the way, including the right standard of review, a possible saving construction, and the interests the statute serves. The state offered only one general justification, protecting residential privacy. It didn't show how requiring a name and a phone number, rather than just a phone number, was narrowly tailored or necessary to that interest.
The court's big point: "The public interest is not well served when a federal statute is challenged and potentially invalidated in litigation among private parties, or even in litigation involving state governments, in the absence of input from the institution that has the responsibility and expertise to defend Acts of Congress."
What Happens on Remand
The court vacated the judgment and provided a roadmap for the parties on remand.
- If the Attorney General intervenes, he can raise new arguments and present new evidence, free of law of the case or other preclusion limits.
- If he doesn't, the district court reinstates its earlier opinion, and any later appeal will be decided on the briefs and argument already submitted.
Why It Matters
- Constitutional attacks on the TCPA carry a notice duty. Challengers should serve the Attorney General under Rule 5.1.
- Notifying the FCC isn't the same thing. State enforcement notice under § 227(f)(1) is a different requirement.
- Thin records invite remand. Waived arguments made this case a poor vehicle for deciding a First Amendment question without federal input.
Vacated and remanded.
Read the full Tenth Circuit opinion.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
