Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Henderson v. United Student Aid Funds: Ninth Circuit Allows Ratification Theory Against a Loan Owner for Debt Collectors' Calls
A student loan guarantor that never contracted with the collectors calling its borrowers may still face vicarious liability under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) if it ratified their calling practices. In Henderson v. United Student Aid Funds, Inc., No. 17-55373, 918 F.3d 1068 (9th Cir. Mar. 22, 2019) (amended on denial of rehearing May 6, 2019), a divided panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit reversed summary judgment for the loan owner and remanded.
On this page
The bottom line: there is no per se creditor liability under Federal Communications Commission (FCC) orders, but a principal that accepts the benefits of a collection program while knowing of, or willfully ignoring, likely violations can be found to have ratified them.
Background
Shyriaa Henderson defaulted on student loans made under the Federal Family Education Loan Program. United Student Aid Funds, Inc. (USA Funds) owned the loans. It hired a loan servicer, Navient Solutions, which in turn hired debt collectors. Five collectors called Henderson with prerecorded messages, many times in short intervals, on a number she had not provided in connection with her loans. She alleged that they combined skip tracing and autodialing.
USA Funds had no contract with the collectors. But it had access to the servicer's performance reports, reviewed collectors' calling notes when issues arose, could ask the servicer to replace collectors and conducted annual audits. Audits in 2000, 2009 and 2010 found calls to numbers borrowers had not consented to, flagged "improper collection practices" and recommended "corrective action." The same collectors were still used. Henderson's claims against the servicer and collectors were dismissed for lack of personal jurisdiction, leaving USA Funds. The district court granted it summary judgment.
The majority opinion
Judge D.W. Nelson wrote for the majority (joined by Judge W. Fletcher).
- No per se liability. The FCC's 2008 ruling said calls by a third party collector are treated as if the creditor placed them. But the FCC's 2013 Dish Network ruling, and the Ninth Circuit's decision in Gomez v. Campbell-Ewald, require federal common law agency principles. Liability is not automatic.
- Labels do not control. Independent contractor language in the agreements was not dispositive, and courts may consider whether parties characterize a relationship to avoid liability.
- Ratification can create agency. Under the Restatement (Third) of Agency, ratification can create an agency relationship where an actor who is not an agent purports to be one. The court distinguished Kristensen v. Credit Payment Services, where an unidentified texting publisher never purported to act for the lenders. Here, collectors told borrowers they were calling about USA Funds loans and negotiated, deferred and accepted payments for it. In its amended opinion, the court added that an earlier Ninth Circuit decision applied California agency law, which is distinct from federal common law.
- Triable issues on both forms of ratification. A jury could find actual knowledge: USA Funds knew that autodialing and skip tracing were common, its audits flagged potential violations, and it continued to accept loan payments without acting. Unlike the defendant in Hodgin v. UTC Fire & Security Americas, it did not cut ties with offending vendors. Alternatively, a jury could find willful ignorance, because the audit findings should have prompted further investigation. The court did not reach implied actual authority.
Horton v. Molina on attributing texts to the insurer
The dissent
Judge Bybee agreed that there was no per se liability but would have affirmed. In his view, skip tracing and autodialing are each lawful, the record did not show USA Funds knew that they were combined, and the evidence showed that it reported problems and recommended corrective action. He wrote that the majority's approach "sounds in strict liability" and that regulators or Congress should address any industry problem. He voted for rehearing, which was denied.
Practical takeaways
- Creditors and loan owners should require TCPA compliance from servicers and downstream vendors and verify it.
- Audit findings that flag potential violations need documented follow-up, not just recommendations.
- Layered vendor structures do not by themselves insulate a principal.
Read the Ninth Circuit's opinion in Henderson v. United Student Aid Funds.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- Opinion, Henderson v. United Student Aid Funds, Inc., No. 17-55373 (9th Cir. filed Mar. 22, 2019)
- Opinion, Henderson v. United Student Aid Funds, Inc., No. 17-55373 (9th Cir. filed Mar. 22, 2019) (2)
- Order denying rehearing and amending opinion, No. 17-55373 (9th Cir. May 6, 2019)
- Opinion, Henderson v. United Student Aid Funds, Inc., No. 17-55373 (9th Cir. filed Mar. 22, 2019).
