Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Hodgin v. UTC Fire & Security: When a Manufacturer Pushes Back on Its Dealers' Robocalls, It Didn't Ratify Them
If you make products that other companies resell through telemarketing, here's the question that keeps you up at night: am I on the hook when a dealer breaks the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA)? In Hodgin v. UTC Fire & Security Americas Corp., No. 17-1222, 885 F.3d 243 (4th Cir. Mar. 14, 2018), the Fourth Circuit said two home security manufacturers weren't, because they responded to complaints, investigated and eventually cut the dealers off.
On this page
The setup
This came out of a multidistrict litigation in the Northern District of West Virginia that consolidated class actions against home security retailers accused of prerecorded calls and calls to numbers on the National Do Not Call Registry. Plaintiffs also named two manufacturers, UTC Fire & Security and Honeywell, on a vicarious liability theory.
UTC. UTC sold security systems to distributors, which resold them to about 28,000 retailers. UTC got nothing directly from retail sales. One retailer, Versatile Marketing Solutions (VMS), had a dealer agreement (inherited when UTC bought GE Security) letting it call itself an "Authorized GE Security Dealer." The agreement barred using the brand in telemarketing scripts, disclaimed any agency relationship and required legal compliance. When complaints about Do Not Call and robocalls came in, UTC followed up with the people who complained, told VMS about them, made VMS's head attend an ethics presentation and ended the dealer agreement in April 2012.
Honeywell. Honeywell sold through a subsidiary distributor. ISI Alarms NC signed a sales agreement in April 2012 that barred it from claiming to be Honeywell's agent. When complaints about prerecorded calls and ignored do-not-call requests arrived that spring, Honeywell investigated, sent executives to ISI's headquarters and warned that the relationship was in jeopardy. ISI attributed the problems to competitors impersonating ISI and hired a compliance consultant. When complaints continued, Honeywell terminated the agreement in January 2013.
The district court granted the manufacturers' summary judgment motion before discovery closed.
What the Fourth Circuit held
Judge Duncan wrote for the panel, joined by Judges Keenan and Diaz. The court affirmed on everything.
The Rule 56(d) request was properly denied. The plaintiffs wanted more depositions before the court ruled. But they'd already deposed both companies and didn't schedule a single deposition in the three months after the case came off a stay. The question isn't whether discovery is still open. It's whether you had a reasonable chance to get what you need. And their declaration just recited the generic benefits of any deposition without identifying evidence that would create a real dispute.
No ratification. On appeal the plaintiffs relied only on ratification. Under the Federal Communications Commission's (FCC's) 2013 Dish Network ruling, vicarious liability follows federal common law agency principles, including ratification. Under the Restatement (Third) of Agency, you can ratify by failing to object or by keeping the benefits, but only if you know the material facts. The plaintiffs' three theories all failed:
Horton v. Molina on attributing texts to the insurer
- Failure to repudiate. The evidence showed that the manufacturers repudiated the dealer's conduct and the plaintiffs failed to rebut this evidence.
- Rebates as rewards. Volume rebates weren't shown to reward illegal calls. The link was speculative, and nothing showed the manufacturers knew sales were driven by robocalls or Do Not Call violations when they signed the agreements.
- Accepting benefits. There was no evidence that illegal telemarketing actually increased the dealers' sales, and therefore their purchases.
Why this matters
Hodgin is basically a roadmap for what a manufacturer's response should look like. Compare it with the Ninth Circuit's later decision in Henderson v. United Student Aid Funds, which distinguished Hodgin because the defendant there didn't cut ties with the problem vendors.
Practical points:
- Put telemarketing restrictions and compliance duties in your dealer agreements.
- Have a real complaint process: follow up, document it and tell the dealer.
- Investigate, escalate and be willing to terminate.
- If you're a plaintiff, get your depositions done and be specific in any Rule 56(d) declaration.
Read the Fourth Circuit's opinion in Hodgin v. UTC Fire & Security.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- Opinion, Hodgin v. UTC Fire & Security Americas Corp., No. 17-1222 (4th Cir. decided Mar. 14, 2018)
- Opinion, Hodgin v. UTC Fire & Security Americas Corp., No. 17-1222 (4th Cir. decided Mar. 14, 2018) (2)
- Opinion, Hodgin v. UTC Fire & Security Americas Corp., No. 17-1222 (4th Cir. decided Mar. 14, 2018).
