Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Mission Hills Federal: The Student Loan "Servicer" That Kept the Payments
Here's a nasty twist on the student loan debt relief playbook. Charging illegal upfront fees wasn't enough. According to the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), the operators behind Mission Hills Federal and Federal Direct Group also got people to send them their monthly loan payments, and then mostly kept the money.
On this page
Who Got Sued
In July 2019, the FTC sued a group of companies in the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California: Elegant Solutions, Inc. (doing business as Federal Direct Group), Trend Capital Ltd. (doing business as Mission Hills Federal), Dark Island Industries, Inc., Heritage Asset Management, Inc. (doing business as National Secure Processing), and Tribune Management, Inc. (doing business as The Student Loan Group). Individuals Mazen Radwan, Rima Radwan, and Dean Robbins were also named, while Labiba Velazquez was added in an amended complaint in August 2019. The court entered a temporary restraining order on July 10, 2019.
The FTC said the scheme took more than $23 million from thousands of consumers.
How the Calls Went
According to the FTC complaint, the defendants made outbound telemarketing calls to student loan borrowers. Some consumers also found the websites and contacted them.
On the calls, telemarketers often cited a new monthly payment that was half or less of what the borrower was paying. One consumer who had been paying $200 a month was told her new payment would be $50. The pitch, according to the FTC, included three big promises:
- Lower payments or forgiveness through consolidation or income-based repayment
- Payments to the defendants would go toward the student loans
- The defendants would take over servicing the loans
The FTC said that in reality, the defendants applied only minimal payments to consumers' loans, or in many cases none at all. They also allegedly collected hundreds to thousands of dollars in illegal upfront fees.
And here's the part that made it worse. The FTC said the defendants got consumers' FSA ID credentials (the login for U.S. Department of Education websites) and changed their contact information. That kept the real loan servicers from reaching borrowers. The FTC said many people went months or years before finding out their loans weren't being paid.
The Rules They Broke
The FTC charged violations of the FTC Act and the Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR). Under the TSR, debt relief sellers can't collect fees until they've actually settled or changed the terms of a debt and the customer has made a payment under that new deal. The TSR also prohibits misrepresentation of any material aspect of a debt relief service.
Shut Down, Contracts Voided, $400,000 Penalty: CFPB's Order Against Western Benefits Group
How It Ended
In July 2020, the court granted the FTC summary judgment and found the defendants violated the FTC Act and the TSR. The final order permanently banned them from telemarketing and debt relief and imposed a $27.6 million judgment. The defendants appealed, but in June 2022 the Ninth Circuit affirmed the ruling.
In March 2024, the FTC sent more than $4.1 million in refunds to 27,584 consumers.
The Lesson
Federal student loan help is available directly from the U.S. Department of Education or the borrower's servicer at no cost, as the FTC pointed out. If you sell student loan services by phone, you don't get paid up front, you don't pose as the servicer, and you definitely don't touch the borrower's login.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- https://www.ftc.gov/legal-library/browse/cases-proceedings/192-3105-elegant-solutions-inc-mission-hills-federal
- https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2020/07/court-rules-ftcs-favor-against-student-debt-relief-scammers
- The FTC's July 2019 complaint against Elegant Solutions, Trend Capital (Mission Hills Federal), and related defendants.
