Analysis · Litigation & decisions
Standard Industries and Midway: Unordered Light Bulbs, Business Calls and an $11.6 Million Refund
In July 2014, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) got a court order stopping and freezing the assets of a Maryland-based office supply operation that used names like Midway Industries and Standard Industries. The FTC alleged that it telemarketed to nonprofits, businesses and municipalities and then shipped and billed them for overpriced light bulbs and cleaning supplies they never ordered. The defendants later were barred from telemarketing those supplies.
On this page
The bottom line: calls to businesses are not automatically exempt from the Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR). Sales of nondurable office and cleaning supplies are specifically covered.
Here is what happened
The complaint was filed in the U.S. District Court for the District of Maryland (case no. 1:14-cv-02312-JFM), and the court entered a temporary restraining order on July 21, 2014. According to the FTC, the defendants called organizations nationwide and falsely said that:
- They had done business with the organization before.
- The call was to confirm a shipping or mailing address or follow up on a previous order.
- They were offering a free sample, catalog or gift.
- They needed an employee's name and contact information for a purpose other than a sale.
The defendants often did not identify themselves accurately or disclose that it was a sales call, the FTC alleged. They shipped merchandise without disclosing a price and sent invoices far above market price. The employee who paid invoices was often not the one who received the shipment. Organizations that paid became targets for more shipments. Those who questioned invoices were told of order recordings that were never produced, or offered a "discount."
The defendants were charged with violating the FTC Act, the TSR and the Unordered Merchandise Statute.
Read the FTC's complaint against Midway Industries and related companies.
The result
The court entered settlement or default orders against all defendants. As announced by the FTC in July 2017, the orders:
- Ban the companies and their principals from telemarketing nondurable office or cleaning supplies.
- Prohibit misrepresenting a prior business relationship, a free sample or catalog offer, or that goods were ordered, in selling anything.
- Prohibit violations of the TSR and the Unordered Merchandise Statute.
- Impose judgments of more than $58 million each (one is $44 million), all suspended based on inability to pay.
A court-appointed receiver took over assets valued at more than $5 million. In August 2019, the FTC mailed 29,333 refund checks totaling more than $11.6 million, an average of $396.
"Scam artists who lie to employees about orders and then demand payment are a magnet for FTC enforcement," said Jessica Rich, then Director of the FTC's Bureau of Consumer Protection.
The law in plain English
The TSR generally exempts calls between a telemarketer and a business. That exemption does not apply to calls to induce the retail sale of nondurable office or cleaning supplies, and does not apply to the TSR's prohibitions on misrepresentations. Under the Unordered Merchandise Statute, recipients of unordered goods may keep them as a gift and are not obligated to pay.
Fake Toner, Real Prison: 79-Year-Old Gets 4 Years for a Decades-Long Telemarketing Scheme
What this means for you
- Identify your company and state that the call is a sales call.
- Never claim a prior relationship or order that does not exist.
- Disclose the price before shipping anything.
- Ship only with a documented, verifiable order from an authorized buyer.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
Primary sources
- FTC case page, Standard Industries LLC
- FTC, "FTC Stops Deceptive Office Supply Scam That Targeted Small Businesses, Nonprofits" (July 2014)
- FTC, orders announcement (July 2017)
- FTC, refunds announcement (Aug. 2019)
- Telemarketing Sales Rule, 16 C.F.R. 310.6
- FTC complaint, FTC v. Midway Industries LLC, et al. (Standard Industries), No. 1:14-cv-02312-JFM (D. Md. filed July 21, 2014).
