Analysis · Litigation & decisions
Fake Toner, Real Prison: 79-Year-Old Gets 4 Years for a Decades-Long Telemarketing Scheme
"Hi, it's your toner supplier. Prices just went up, but we can lock you in at the old price today."
On this page
Sound familiar? If you've ever run an office, I bet it does.
What happened?
On September 3, 2021, the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Central District of California, part of the Department of Justice (DOJ), announced that Gilbert N. Michaels, 79, of West Los Angeles, was sentenced to 48 months in federal prison plus 28 months of home confinement. U.S. District Judge James V. Selna also fined him $200,000.
In December 2019, after a six-week trial, a jury found Michaels guilty of conspiracy to commit mail fraud, 10 counts of mail fraud and five counts of money laundering.
How the scheme worked
Michaels owned and ran IDC Servco and Mytel International. Working with boiler room operators, the companies sold toner to businesses, charities and other organizations across the country.
- Telemarketers posed as the victims' regular toner supplier.
- They said prices had gone up and offered the "old, lower price."
- Michaels gave the boiler rooms price catalogs listing toner at up to five to 10 times retail.
- Many victims were already getting toner free under their copier and printer contracts.
- Employees signed "order confirmation" forms, IDC shipped toner and sent inflated invoices.
- Complaints got the same answer: no cancellation, no refund, because you signed.
- IDC employees often threatened collections or legal action. Returns came with big "restocking fees."
Over one six-year span, victims sent more than $126 million to the telemarketing scammers. More than 50,000 victims in all. Read that again.
And there's more. Court orders going back to November 1988 barred Michaels and his companies from false statements and required them to oversee "independent sales companies." He violated them by working with and financing those supposedly independent boiler rooms, even as IDC received hundreds of thousands of complaints.
Six other defendants were also found guilty with Michaels in December 2019.
Here's the thing ...
Court orders from 1988. Sentenced in 2021.
That's more than 30 years of being told "stop," and not stopping. The "independent" boiler rooms were a shield. The judge didn't buy it, and neither did the jury.
If you rely on "independent" sales partners, you'd better actually oversee them. Calling them independent doesn't make their calls any less yours.
What to do this week
- Never pose as a customer's existing vendor.
- Oversee your sales partners for real. Listen to calls.
- Don't hide behind a signed form if the sale was deceptive.
- Read your complaints. Hundreds of thousands is not "noise."
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
