Analysis · Litigation & decisions
Unordered Textbooks, Cold Calls and a Pirate Alias: A False Claims Act Telemarketing Settlement
The bottom line: a Pennsylvania couple and their telemarketing company agreed to a proposed $75,689 civil penalty and a ban on unsolicited marketing to federal agencies, to resolve allegations that they shipped unordered textbooks to federal prisons and demanded payment.
On this page
What happened
On June 26, 2018, the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, part of the Department of Justice (DOJ), announced a civil complaint under the False Claims Act against John Paul Ryan and Mary Motz Ryan of Bucks County, Pennsylvania, and their telemarketing company, Scholars in Print. The government also filed a joint motion asking the court to enter a stipulated order and consent judgment. The resolution required court approval.
The allegations
According to the complaint:
- Scholars in Print made unsolicited telemarketing calls to Federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP) facilities nationwide to sell textbooks for prison libraries.
- Most facilities declined. The company shipped textbooks anyway and sent unpaid bills to collection agencies.
- When confronted, the company allegedly claimed the facilities had ordered the books during the calls. The complaint alleges that was false.
- At other times, the company allegedly offered a free sample and then invoiced for it.
The complaint gives several examples. In one, an official refused to buy during a call, and later emailed to confirm the refusal. A few weeks later, the company allegedly shipped books to that same official. In another, John Ryan allegedly identified himself as Edward Teach, the real name of the pirate Blackbeard, offered a free sample to a prison psychologist, and then invoiced $331. According to the complaint, Ryan told investigators he sometimes used that name because "you don't want people to know your name."
The DOJ Office of the Inspector General (DOJ OIG) led the investigation. These are allegations only, not findings of liability.
The proposed resolution
If approved, the defendants would pay a civil penalty of $75,689 and would refrain from marketing products to any federal agency through unsolicited communications or telemarketing.
Why it matters
Three lessons apply to every telemarketer. First, a "yes" must be real and documented. Claiming an order that was never placed creates liability. Second, a free sample must be free. Third, callers should identify themselves truthfully. On consumer sales calls, the Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR) requires prompt disclosure of the seller's identity. Calls to businesses and agencies are largely outside the TSR, but fraud laws still apply, and when the buyer is the government, the False Claims Act adds another layer of exposure.
Practical steps
- Record or document every order, including who agreed and when.
- Honor refusals and do not ship without confirmation.
- Never bill for "free" items.
- Require truthful caller identification on every call.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
