Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Spanish Survey Texts, a Grammar Fight and Judge Barrett: Gadelhak v. AT&T
Ali Gadelhak doesn't speak Spanish. He isn't an AT&T customer. His number is on the National Do Not Call Registry.
On this page
AT&T texted him five survey questions in Spanish anyway.
He sued. And in Gadelhak v. AT&T Services, Inc., No. 19-1738, 950 F.3d 458 (7th Cir. Feb. 19, 2020), then-Judge Amy Coney Barrett wrote an opinion that opens like this: "The wording of the provision that we interpret today is enough to make a grammarian throw down her pen."
Chief Judge Wood and Judge Kanne were on the panel. The court affirmed the win for AT&T.
So what happened?
AT&T's "Customer Rules Feedback Tool" sends out surveys to customers who've used AT&T customer service. It pulls numbers from a customer database. It doesn't generate random numbers. AT&T figured Gadelhak received the texts because of a typo.
Gadelhak filed a class action under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) arguing that the tool is an "automatic telephone dialing system."
First: does he even have standing?
Here's the thing ... AT&T didn't challenge standing, but the court checked anyway because the circuits were split.
The court said yes, he has standing. Unwanted texts resemble the old common law claim for intrusion upon seclusion, which covered phone calls repeated "with such persistence and frequency as to amount to a course of hounding." Congress called telemarketing a "nuisance" and an "intrusive invasion of privacy."
The court looked for a match "in kind, not degree." And a few texts will do. It disagreed with the Eleventh Circuit's Salcedo v. Hanna decision, saying the buzz of a text and the ring of a call are both intrusions on peace and quiet.
Then: the grammar fight
The statute defines an autodialer as equipment with the capacity "to store or produce telephone numbers to be called, using a random or sequential number generator" and to dial them.
The court lays out four possibilities:
- The generator modifies both "store" and "produce." The Third and Eleventh Circuits' view.
- It describes how the numbers were generated. The district court's view, but it added a word that wasn't there.
- It modifies only "produce." That's the Ninth Circuit's Marks reading, which would cover anything that stores and dials numbers.
- It describes how numbers are "to be called." The comma placement cuts against it.
The court picked number one. Imperfect, it said, but the best of the bunch.
And it had a great line against reading three. Under that view, every iPhone is an autodialer. Turn on "Do Not Disturb While Driving" and your phone auto-texts people back. That would mean $500 for every unconsented text from an iPhone.
Read that again. Every iPhone.
Why should you care?
This one aged well. About a year later, the Supreme Court adopted a similar reading in Facebook, Inc. v. Duguid. So the autodialer argument for database-driven texting is mostly dead.
But the standing part still matters in the Seventh Circuit. A few texts will get you into court.
What to do this week
- Fix your data entry. A typo sent these texts to a stranger.
- Scrub against the Do Not Call Registry for anything marketing related.
- Don't treat "no autodialer" as a free pass. Prerecorded voice, Do Not Call and state rules still apply.
- Honor opt-outs fast, including from people who aren't your customers.
The grammar saved AT&T this time. Good data hygiene is cheaper.
Read the Seventh Circuit's opinion in Gadelhak v. AT&T Services.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
