Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Anthony v. National Republican Congressional Committee: 62 Campaign Texts, No Autodialer Claim, and a Second Look at the State Claim
Election season texts are a rite of passage. In Anthony v. National Republican Congressional Committee, No. 24-3052 (3d Cir. Sept. 26, 2025), a Third Circuit panel affirmed the dismissal of a Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) autodialer class action over 62 campaign texts. But it revived the plaintiff's state law privacy claim with a useful lesson about class action jurisdiction. The opinion is not precedential, so it binds only this case.
On this page
The Texts
The plaintiff, a Pennsylvania resident, said he got 62 texts from the committee during the 2020 election season, including after he asked them to stop. He sued for himself and a putative class with two TCPA counts and a Pennsylvania claim for intrusion upon seclusion. The district court dismissed the TCPA counts with prejudice for failing to allege use of an autodialer, and then dismissed the state claim for lack of jurisdiction.
Capacity Is Not Enough in the Third Circuit
The complaint alleged that the texting equipment "had the capacity to store or produce telephone numbers to be called, using a random or sequential number generator." That sounds like the statute, right?
Not enough here. Under Panzarella v. Navient Solutions, Inc., 37 F.4th 867 (3d Cir. 2022), the plaintiff has to allege the system actually used random or sequential number generation to make the calls, not just that it could. Picking targets from a curated list doesn't count. And his lawyer had admitted at oral argument that he couldn't allege the numbers were randomly generated rather than uploaded from a list. Amendment would be futile.
The plaintiff argued that Facebook, Inc. v. Duguid, 592 U.S. 395 (2021), doesn't make random generation a required element. The panel said Panzarella already read the element that way after Duguid, and only the full court can overrule it.
There's a fun footnote on "information and belief" pleading too. The panel said those allegations aren't automatically presumed true but can be credited when other allegations make them reasonable. That didn't matter here, because the capacity allegation failed regardless.
The Twist: When Do You Measure the Amount in Controversy?
The state privacy claim depended on the Class Action Fairness Act (CAFA), which requires more than $5 million in controversy. The district court reasoned that once the TCPA claims were gone, the leftover privacy claim couldn't get there.
The panel said that was backwards. The amount in controversy is measured when the complaint is filed, not after some claims get dismissed. At filing, the plaintiff alleged texts to thousands of people, with $500 to $1,500 per TCPA violation. It wasn't a legal certainty that the total stayed under $5 million. So the court had jurisdiction, and the dismissal of the privacy claim was vacated and sent back for a ruling on the merits.
The panel added a footnote that the complaint said the plaintiff was a Pennsylvania "resident," but diversity turns on citizenship. That defect could be cured on remand.
Takeaways
In the Third Circuit, an autodialer claim requires facts to show that random or sequential number generation was actually used. Lists won't cut it. For defendants, beating the TCPA count doesn't automatically end the class case if CAFA jurisdiction existed at filing. Expect to defend the state law claims on the merits.
Read the Third Circuit opinion in Anthony v. National Republican Congressional Committee.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
