Analysis · Litigation & decisions
Shelton v. Pro Source Lending: The Employee Who Dialed Can Be Sued Too
If you personally make the telemarketing calls, can you be sued alongside your employer? In Shelton v. Pro Source Lending Group LLC, No. 24-4394 (E.D. Pa. Mar. 14, 2025), Judge Gerald Austin McHugh said yes, and he denied both defendants' motions to dismiss a Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) class complaint.
On this page
Eight Contacts in 24 Hours
Plaintiff registered his number with the National Do Not Call Registry in 2015. He alleged that in July 2024, a Pro Source employee called him from her personal cell about a loan and texted on behalf of "Fast Funds Group," a name Pro Source does business under. More contacts followed the next day, including a text minutes after he emailed asking her to stop. The court treated the five calls and three texts as eight calls.
There was history. The plaintiff previously sued Pro Source in 2021, and the parties settled. He alleged he asked to be placed on Pro Source's internal do not call list during that process.
A Number With a Past
The wrinkle: in 2019, another judge in the same district dismissed a different TCPA suit by the plaintiff because the same number was then listed on his business website and used for mixed purposes. The defendants argued that ruling should carry over.
Judge McHugh disagreed on two fronts:
- No collateral estoppel. The plaintiff alleged he stopped all business use in June 2019, got a separate business line, and has used this number only for personal purposes since. That's a different issue from the one decided in 2019. No authority said past business use permanently strips protection from a registered number.
- No equitable estoppel. If the plaintiff had pulled the number off his website and immediately sued, the court would be "strongly inclined" to find estoppel. But nearly five years had passed. The burden is on the caller to make sure a number isn't protected, and Pro Source could have checked.
Litigation History and the Zone of Interests
Pro Source also argued that the plaintiff's prior TCPA lawsuits put him outside the statute's zone of interests, citing Stoops v. Wells Fargo, where a plaintiff bought dozens of phones to generate claims. The court rejected that argument at this stage. The plaintiff has two numbers, not 35, and there was no evidence he advertised his personal number to attract calls. Eight contacts in 24 hours "would seem to be conduct the TCPA is intended to address."
The Internal List Claim
Pro Source said it had 30 days to honor the July 2024 stop request. But taking the allegations as true, the request dated back to the 2021 settlement, two and a half years earlier. That states a claim under 47 C.F.R. § 64.1200(d).
Yes, the Employee Too
The employee argued there's no individual liability under the TCPA. The court pointed to 47 U.S.C. § 217, which treats the act of any agent or employee acting within the scope of employment as the act of both the company and "that person." She was allegedly directly involved, using her own phone. The defense leaned on City Select Auto Sales v. David Randall Associates (3d Cir. 2018), but the court said that case addressed a jury instruction on corporate officer liability in "pure dicta" and can't be read as "repealing the clear language of the statute."
Takeaways
- Individual callers can face personal claims for their own calls.
- A stop request made during a settlement can count for internal list purposes.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
