Case analysis · Litigation & decisions

Kemen v. Cincinnati Bell: Online Reviews, a Cold-Calling Job Posting and Class Allegations Survive a Motion to Strike

In Kemen v. Cincinnati Bell Telephone Co., LLC, No. 1:22-cv-152 (S.D. Ohio Mar. 22, 2024), Judge Douglas R. Cole denied in full a motion to strike online reviews, a job posting and class allegations and treated a renewed motion to dismiss as disguised reconsideration.

By Harrison GevirtzPublished 2 min read
On this page

The Allegations

The plaintiff alleged she filled out an online quote request on the defendant's website in January 2022. A sales employee then called her cell phone, followed by another call one minute later and a third call five days later. A sales email followed. She replied asking not to be emailed or called, and the employee acknowledged the request. About a week later she received a fourth call from another company number. She sued on behalf of a putative class under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) and the internal do not call rule, 47 C.F.R. § 64.1200(d).

The court dismissed the first amended complaint because it did not plausibly plead that she was a residential subscriber. It then granted leave to file a second amended complaint, finding all four elements plausibly alleged, including the absence of minimum internal procedures. The plaintiff withdrew her claim of injunctive relief.

A Motion to Dismiss That Was Really Reconsideration

The defendant answered but also moved to dismiss again, arguing the same internal procedures point. The court looked past the label. Because the motion merely re-raised a rejected argument, it was a motion for reconsideration. With no intervening change in law, new evidence or clear error, it failed.

The court added a practical note. Whether minimum procedures existed and whether the defendant's delay in honoring the request was reasonable are factual questions. A defendant confident in its procedures can produce them and move for summary judgment, and the plaintiff can seek targeted discovery under Rule 56(d) if needed.

The Online Complaints and Job Posting Stay

The defendant sought to strike a job posting that listed cold calling and lead lists as duties, two anonymous Better Business Bureau complaints from consumers who said calls continued after stop requests, and employee reviews on a job site that described speed dialers and cold calls.

Motions to strike are disfavored and granted only when the material has no possible relation to the controversy. The court did not rely on this material for the plaintiff's individual claim and noted the anonymous complaints may present hearsay problems. But if proven with admissible evidence, the job posting and reviews could bear on willfulness and treble damages, and the consumer complaints could support class requirements.

The Class Allegations Stay

The proposed class covered people called more than once in 12 months for the same reason, with at least one call after a stop request. The defendant said the class was overbroad because it would include nonresidential subscribers and that consent issues would predominate. To strike now, it had to show certification would be impossible regardless of the facts. It could not. If the defendant keeps records of stop requests and marketing calls, membership is an identification issue, and the definition itself limits the class to people who objected and were called again.

Practical Points

  • Re-raising a rejected pleading argument invites a reconsideration standard, not a fresh look.
  • Pleading-stage strikes of online complaints rarely succeed when the material is pleaded as context rather than as proof of an element.

Read the Southern District of Ohio opinion and order.

Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.

Primary sources

  1. Opinion and Order, Kemen v. Cincinnati Bell Telephone Co., LLC, No. 1:22-cv-152 (S.D. Ohio Mar. 22, 2024)
  2. Opinion and Order, Kemen v. Cincinnati Bell Telephone Co., LLC (S.D. Ohio Mar. 22, 2024).
Harrison Gevirtz, Chief Strategy Officer of Ringba, Las Vegas, Nevada

About the Author: Harrison Gevirtz

Harrison Gevirtz serves as the Chief Strategy Officer (CSO) of Ringba, a call tracking and pay per call platform, and is based in Las Vegas, Nevada. Harrison Gevirtz is a serial operator in call tracking, call routing and telemarketing operations, and for the past several years he has focused on how federal regulations affect the daily operations of these industries. At TCPA.com, Harrison Gevirtz covers TCPA litigation, Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR) enforcement, tech support fraud prosecutions and Federal Communications Commission (FCC) rulemaking in a way that's accessible to the non-lawyer executive or compliance manager.

More from Harrison Gevirtz

Topics