Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Pasco v. Protus IP Solutions: Fax Broadcasters, Limitations, and Who Can Sue Under Maryland's Calling Law
The Maryland Telephone Consumer Protection Act (MTCPA) makes violations of the federal Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) violations of state law. In Pasco v. Protus IP Solutions, Inc., No. RDB-08-3388 (D. Md. Nov. 23, 2011), Judge Richard D. Bennett ruled on cross-motions for summary judgment in a junk fax case against a fax broadcasting company and answered a number questions about how the two statutes interact.
On this page
Background
Five plaintiffs, one individual and four businesses, alleged they received about 357 unsolicited fax advertisements transmitted by a Canadian fax broadcaster. The plaintiffs relied on header styles and toll-free removal numbers to link the faxes to the company. The company argued those features were not unique, and it identified 79 faxes with no matching record in its transmission data.
Liability Goes to Trial
Conflicting affidavits about whether the company sent the faxes created a jury question. But the plaintiffs offered no evidence rebutting the absence of transmission records for the 79 faxes, so the company won summary judgment on those.
Constitutional Challenges Rejected
The company devoted much of its brief to attacking the statutes. The court rejected each argument:
- Statutory damages. Punitive damages precedents did not apply to statutory damages. The $500 to $1,500 range was not "so severe and oppressive" as to violate due process.
- First Amendment. Under the commercial speech framework, the government's interest in preventing cost shifting and business interruption were substantial despite cheaper fax technology. Congress could reasonably limit only commercial faxes.
- Vagueness. The definition of "unsolicited advertisement" was sufficiently clear.
The Fax Broadcaster Defense
The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) regulations defined a fax broadcaster as one who transmits faxes for others for a fee. A broadcaster is only liable if it demonstrates "a high degree of involvement in, or actual notice of, the unlawful activity" and fails to take steps to prevent the transmissions. The court deferred to that framework as a reasonable construction of the statute.
The company fit the definition of a fax broadcaster. Whether it had a high degree of involvement was a jury question. The plaintiffs' evidence that unrelated advertisers sent them the same faxes was "thin" but was enough to suggest that the company may have helped supply fax numbers.
Limitations and Tolling
Federal TCPA claims have a four year limitations period. Following the Court of Appeals of Maryland's answer to a certified question, MTCPA claims carry three years. The claims accrued on receipt of each fax. The court rejected equitable tolling because nothing suggested active concealment, and Maryland law disfavors implied exceptions.
Only Individuals Can Recover Under the MTCPA
The MTCPA's damages provision allows "an individual who is affected by a violation" to sue. Maryland law defines "individual" as a natural person, while "person" includes corporations. The four business plaintiffs therefore lacked standing to recover under the MTCPA.
Boger on claims under Maryland’s telephone law
Other Rulings
The court held that the Telemarketing Sales Rule's caller identification requirement did not apply to fax advertising. It concluded, preliminarily, that plaintiffs likely cannot recover damages under both the TCPA and the MTCPA for the same fax, leaving final resolution for later briefing.
Takeaways
- Broadcasters are not automatically exempt. Involvement in fax numbers or content can create liability.
- Transmission records matter. Unrebutted records can eliminate claims.
- Businesses should plead federally. The MTCPA's damages remedy belongs to natural persons.
Read the full District of Maryland opinion.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
