Case analysis · Litigation & decisions
Gordon v. Robinhood Financial: Washington Court Certifies a Class Over "Refer a Friend" Texts Under the State's Commercial Electronic Mail Act
Referral programs feel like word of mouth. Under Washington law, they can also be a source of class-wide liability. In Gordon v. Robinhood Financial LLC, No. 2:19-cv-0390 (E.D. Wash. Jan. 25, 2021), Judge Thomas O. Rice certified a class of Washington residents who received referral texts generated through a brokerage app's "Refer a Friend" feature, under the Washington Commercial Electronic Mail Act (CEMA) and Consumer Protection Act (CPA).
On this page
The Program
The brokerage offered a referral program in which an existing customer and a new customer who signed up would each receive one share of free stock. When a customer opted to refer by text, the brokerage created an automated message including a sign-up link, which the customer could edit before sending.
The named plaintiff, a Washington resident, received an unsolicited text in July 2019 reading, "Your free stock is waiting for you! Join Robinhood and we'll both get a stock like Apple, Ford, or Facebook for free. Sign up with my link." It contained no opt-out or "stop" option.
The Statute
RCW 19.190.060(1) provides that no person conducting business in Washington may "initiate or assist in the transmission of an electronic commercial text message" to a Washington resident's cell phone. There is no violation if the recipient gave clear and affirmative consent. Citing the Washington Supreme Court's decision in Wright v. Lyft, the court noted that a CEMA violation together with CEMA's damages provision establishes the injury and causation elements of a CPA claim as a matter of law.
Rule 23(a)
- Numerosity: The company's own sworn estimate, offered earlier to establish the amount in controversy, indicated more than 1,100 potential class members with Washington addresses. That created a common-sense inference that joinder was impracticable.
- Commonality: Whether the referral texts violated CEMA, and thus the CPA, was a significant common question. Consent defenses did not defeat certification.
- Typicality: Every class member suffered the same injury, receipt of an unsolicited commercial text, from the same course of conduct. The Ninth Circuit does not require an administratively feasible method of identifying class members.
- Adequacy: The court rejected the argument that counsel was inadequate for moving to certify before taking discovery.
Rule 23(b)(3)
The company argued that individual questions would predominate: who sent and received each text, residency, whether each message was "commercial," and consent. The court disagreed. Whether edited messages remained commercial was a merits question, and class membership itself would answer receipt, residency, and consent.
Class treatment was also superior. Statutory damages of $500 per text, potentially $1,500 with exemplary damages, are small compared to litigation costs, and there was no competing litigation.
The Certified Class
The class covers Washington residents to whom the company initiated or assisted in transmitting one or more commercial texts without prior clear and affirmative consent, from October 4, 2015 to January 25, 2021.
Takeaways
- Referral features are not a safe harbor. A company that drafts the message and rewards sharing may face claims that it initiated or assisted in the transmission.
- Your own declarations can be used against you. An estimate offered to support federal jurisdiction later supported numerosity.
- Consent is not automatically individualized. The court treated it as a merits issue, not a certification barrier.
Read the court's order.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
