Regulatory update · FCC & rulemaking
He Spoofed So His Own Phone Wouldn't Ring: The FCC's $82 Million Fine Against a Health Insurance Robocaller
This might be my favorite excuse ever.
On this page
A guy makes more than 21 million robocalls. He spoofs the caller ID. Why? According to the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), he argued he did it so his own cell phone wouldn't get "overwhelmed" by people calling back.
Read that again. He didn't want to be bothered by calls.
So what happened?
On September 26, 2018, the FCC imposed an $82,106,000 penalty on Best Insurance Contracts, Inc. (BIC) and Philip Roesel, personally and doing business as Wilmington Insurance Quotes. Read the FCC Forfeiture Order against Best Insurance Contracts and Philip Roesel.
According to the FCC:
- The campaign involved more than 21 million robocalls during a three-month period from late 2016 through early 2017.
- The goal was to generate leads and sell health insurance.
- Roesel retained a robocall dialing platform and relied on spoofed numbers.
- Roesel didn't deny making the calls, and didn't claim he had prior consent from any of the more than 17 million mobile phone consumers.
- The calls also hit an estimated 5,000 to 10,000 medical pagers run by Spōk, Inc., which provides paging services to medical providers. Spōk had contacted the FCC in December 2016.
The FCC had already issued a Notice of Apparent Liability, and its Enforcement Bureau issued a Citation finding Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA) violations for unauthorized prerecorded telemarketing calls.
"But leads are valuable to the consumer!"
Roesel also argued that these leads gave something valuable to people who asked for more information about health insurance.
The FCC wasn't buying it. It found Roesel "wrongfully" used a massive robocalling campaign without consent to get leads and potential commissions. That's the "wrongfully obtain anything of value" part of the Truth in Caller ID Act.
Spoofing Your Own Customers' Numbers: The FCC's $37.5 Million Fine Against Affordable Enterprises
He also argued the company, not him personally, should pay. The FCC said BIC was "a shell corporation" he created to run the campaign. So he's on the hook personally.
Here's the thing ... lead gen is the business here
This one hits close to home for a lot of you. Health insurance leads. Dialing platforms. Commissions. That's a real industry.
And the FCC is saying the lead itself is the "thing of value." So if you spoof to get leads, you've checked the box for the violation.
Am I right? That's a big deal.
What to do this week
- Get consent before any prerecorded call. Written, for telemarketing.
- Use real caller ID that people can call back. Yes, even if they're angry.
- Know where your leads come from. If the source is a robocall blast, walk away.
- Don't hide behind a shell company. It won't work.
It's simple math. 21 million calls and $82 million in penalties.
You're smarter than this. I believe in you. Now go check your lead sources, OK?
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
