Regulatory update · FCC & rulemaking
FCC Fines Scott Rhodes $9.9 Million for Neighbor-Spoofed Robocalls Aimed at Communities in Six States
On January 14, 2021, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) released a Forfeiture Order assessing a $9,918,000 penalty against Scott Rhodes for violating the Truth in Caller ID Act. The FCC found that Rhodes made 4,959 unlawful spoofed robocalls between May 2018 and December 2018.
On this page
The bottom line: spoofing a local number is unlawful when it is done with the intent to cause harm or wrongfully obtain something of value, and the FCC will pursue an individual caller, not only companies.
What happened
The FCC first proposed a $12,910,000 penalty in a Notice of Apparent Liability announced January 30, 2020. According to the FCC's announcement, its Enforcement Bureau found six apparent calling campaigns. The caller apparently used an online calling platform to make his calls look as if they came from local numbers, a technique known as "neighbor spoofing."
The campaigns, as described by the FCC, included:
- California: 1,496 spoofed robocalls in May 2018 about the state's U.S. Senate primary.
- Florida: 766 spoofed robocalls in October 2018 attacking a candidate for governor.
- Georgia: 583 spoofed robocalls in November 2018 attacking a candidate for governor.
- Idaho: 750 spoofed robocalls in September 2018 to residents of Sandpoint, attacking the local newspaper and its publisher after the paper identified him as the robocaller.
- Iowa: 827 spoofed robocalls in August 2018 to residents of Brooklyn, Iowa, following the murder of a local college student.
- Virginia: 2,023 spoofed robocalls in November and December 2018 to residents of Charlottesville during a murder trial. The FCC said the timing suggests an attempt to influence the jury.
The FCC described the content of these calls as racist and anti-Semitic. It said the caller was apparently motivated by a belief that the calls would bring media notoriety and publicity for his website and personal brand.
The final order
The Forfeiture Order was adopted January 13, 2021. Rhodes argued that he did not alter caller ID information and did not intend to cause harm or wrongfully obtain something of value. The FCC rejected those arguments. Read the FCC Forfeiture Order against Scott Rhodes.
The FCC did accept one of his arguments. Rhodes showed he had the right to use one of the caller IDs identified in the notice, so calls using that number were not spoofed. The FCC reduced the penalty by $2,992,000, to $9,918,000.
The law
The Truth in Caller ID Act, 47 U.S.C. § 227(e), and the FCC's rule at 47 C.F.R. § 64.1604 prohibit knowingly causing a caller ID service to transmit misleading or inaccurate caller ID information "with the intent to defraud, cause harm, or wrongfully obtain anything of value." Spoofing by itself is not always unlawful. The intent requirement is what makes it a violation.
Why it matters
This case shows that the FCC treats publicity and attention as something of value, and treats harassment of a community as harm. It also shows that the agency will reduce a penalty when the facts support it, which is why accurate records matter.
What this means for you
- Display only numbers you have the right to use.
- Keep records showing your authority to use each caller ID number.
- Avoid local-presence dialing that displays numbers you do not control.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
