Case analysis · Calls & text messages
Boone's Pharmacy v. EzriRx: The Person Who Answers the Phone Can Say Yes to Your Fax
Who at a business gets to agree to receive fax ads? According to Chief Judge Jeffrey U. Beaverstock in Boone's Pharmacy, Inc. v. EzriRx, LLC, Civil Action No. 22-00375-JB-N (S.D. Ala. July 31, 2023) the employee who answers the phone and confirms a fax number can do so, at least where there's nothing in the complaint to the contrary. The court dismissed a putative junk fax class action under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA).
On this page
The Call
Boone's is a small independent family pharmacy in Demopolis, Alabama. EzriRx runs a pharmaceutical marketplace connecting wholesalers and pharmacies. According to the complaint, EzriRx pulled fax numbers from directories, including one that lists each pharmacy's authorized representative, then had third parties call pharmacies to confirm numbers and get "consent."
In July 2021, a caller contacted Boone's. She explained that she was calling for EzriRx "to confirm your fax number to be able to send you a marketing material about us." The employee who answered said "Yes, ma'am, it is," and told her first name. EzriRx later sent two faxes in September 2022, and the pharmacy sued days later.
Permission Was Clear Enough
The TCPA bans unsolicited fax advertisements, meaning ads sent without "prior express invitation or permission, in writing or otherwise." EzriRx didn't dispute the faxes were ads. The court said the Eleventh Circuit's decision in Gorss Motels v. Safemark Systems establishes that a conversation acknowledging future fax ads like this one counts as prior express permission. But Gorss didn't address whether the person granting permission had authority. So the court turned to agency law.
Apparent Authority Under Alabama Law
The pharmacy pointed to a declaration from its owner that no other employee but him could consent to fax ads. The court said that negated express or implied authority, but not apparent authority. And to the extent it claimed the employee had no authority at all, it was a legal conclusion "masquerading" as fact.
The key facts from the complaint are:
- The employee answered the pharmacy's phone, during business hours, as part of her job.
- Nothing suggested she'd been told of any limits on that role.
- Nothing suggested she couldn't give out or confirm the fax number, which "inevitably invites the receipt of a fax."
By letting her do those things, the pharmacy held her out as having authority to act as she did. The court said Osorio v. State Farm, which the pharmacy cited, actually supports that result.
The Night Janitor Problem
The pharmacy warned that this would mean that anyone who answers a cold call binds the company, like a night janitor or a worker at another location. The court said that its decision makes no such determination. A complaint alleging facts like that might survive. These facts weren't pleaded.
The court also rejected the argument that EzriRx had to go out of its way to find the owner, since it knew who he was from the directory. Requiring a company to seek out an owner before communicating "defies practicality," and knowing who the owner is doesn't mean other employees can't consent.
EzriRx's motion to strike the class allegations was moot. The court also directed EzriRx to say whether it would keep pursuing its counterclaims for breach of contract and negligent misrepresentation.
Takeaways
- A recorded, specific request to send "marketing material" by fax may supply permission.
- Internal limits on who may consent need factual support, not just a declaration.
- Facts showing the person lacked authority could change the result.
Read the Southern District of Alabama order.
Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.
