Case analysis · Litigation & decisions

Bank v. ICOT Holdings: A Weekend Visitor Is Not a "Called Party"

Who could sue over a prerecorded call to a residential landline? In Bank v. ICOT Holdings, LLC, No. 18-CV-02554 (AMD) (PK) (E.D.N.Y. Jan. 25, 2024), Judge Ann M. Donnelly denied a plaintiff's motion for partial summary judgment asking the court to declare him a "called party" under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act (TCPA). He answered calls on his mother's line while visiting. That was not enough.

By Harrison GevirtzPublished 2 min read
On this page

Background

The plaintiff, an attorney proceeding without counsel, answered two prerecorded calls promoting hearing aids at his mother's home, one in 2017 and one in 2018. Each call transferred him to a live person. His mother was the subscriber. He did not live there full time but spent most weekends there, which he described as "a sizeable minority of his time," and he had her permission to answer the phone.

He sued under 47 U.S.C. ยง 227(b)(1)(B), which prohibits prerecorded calls to a residential line without "the prior express consent of the called party," and under the Do Not Call rule. Class certification had already been denied: the proposed class was not ascertainable, and the court found him an inadequate representative of a subscriber-only class because his own status was unsettled. He then moved for partial summary judgment on that status.

The Standard

The TCPA does not define "called party." The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) 2015 order describes it to include a non-subscriber who, due to a relationship with the subscriber, is the number's "customary user" and can consent to calls. Because the plaintiff was not the subscriber, he had to show he was a customary user.

The Holding

He did not. The court found no case holding that someone is a called party where the only connection is spending a sizeable minority of time at the residence with permission to use the phone. The comparison cases involved more: a plaintiff who lived in the apartment for thirteen years and paid the bills, and a plaintiff who shared a household with the subscriber. The plaintiff showed none of that: no primary use, no shared residence and no bill payment.

The court instead likened him to the frequent "houseguest" or "visitor who picks up the phone" that the Third Circuit in Leyse v. Bank of America said likely falls outside the TCPA's zone of interests.

The plaintiff argued that anyone who could validly consent to the calls is a called party, relying on FCC commentary about the cell phone provision. The court rejected this for two reasons. First, the commentary addresses a different provision. Second, the FCC's own guidance cuts the other way: when a houseguest answers, there is no violation if the subscriber or customary user consented. The FCC never suggested the houseguest could supply that consent.

Nor does every person within earshot of a robocall have a federal claim. A regular user who occupies the residence likely could sue; a visitor likely could not.

Procedural Posture Matters

The court distinguished another Eastern District of New York ruling that denied a motion to dismiss because customary user status was a fact question. On summary judgment, the burden was the plaintiff's, and he did not carry it.

Practical Points

  • Plaintiffs: Non-subscriber standing turns on evidence of residence, primary use or bill payment. Weekend visits are slim.
  • Defendants: Challenge statutory standing and class adequacy early when the named plaintiff is not the subscriber.

Read the Eastern District of New York decision.

Not legal advice. TCPA.com provides general information, not legal advice, and is not a substitute for the advice of an attorney. Do not rely on it. Verify any action with your own licensed lawyer before you take it. See our Terms of Use.

Primary sources

  1. Memorandum Decision and Order, Bank v. ICOT Holdings, LLC, No. 18-CV-02554 (E.D.N.Y. Jan. 25, 2024)
  2. Leyse v. Bank of America, National Association, 804 F.3d 316 (3d Cir. 2015)
  3. Memorandum Decision and Order, Bank v. ICOT Holdings, LLC (E.D.N.Y. Jan. 25, 2024).
Harrison Gevirtz, Chief Strategy Officer of Ringba, Las Vegas, Nevada

About the Author: Harrison Gevirtz

Harrison Gevirtz serves as the Chief Strategy Officer (CSO) of Ringba, a call tracking and pay per call platform, and is based in Las Vegas, Nevada. Harrison Gevirtz is a serial operator in call tracking, call routing and telemarketing operations, and for the past several years he has focused on how federal regulations affect the daily operations of these industries. At TCPA.com, Harrison Gevirtz covers TCPA litigation, Telemarketing Sales Rule (TSR) enforcement, tech support fraud prosecutions and Federal Communications Commission (FCC) rulemaking in a way that's accessible to the non-lawyer executive or compliance manager.

More from Harrison Gevirtz

Topics